Liam Neeson is a fine actor (I like the underrated “Taken”) but he is a lousy theologian. Neeson is the voice of Aslan in the Narnia fillms. “The Voyage of the Dawn Treader” launches next week. But now Neeson has angered many Christian fans of the books and films by declaring his Aslan to be way more ecumenical than C.S. Lewis ever intended.
Aslan, of course, is a symbol of Christ. It’s kind of hard to get around that. Especially the death and resurrection thing in the first book. This isn’t stopping Neeson’s interpretation:
“Aslan symbolises a Christ-like figure but he also symbolises for me Mohammed, Buddha and all the great spiritual leaders and prophets over the centuries.
That’s who Aslan stands for as well as a mentor figure for kids – that’s what he means for me.”
This is not sitting well with Narnia fans and those who revere Lewis:
Walter Hooper, Lewis’s former secretary and a trustee of his estate, said that the author would have been angered by Neeson’s comments.
He said: “It is nothing whatever to do with Islam. Lewis would have simply denied that. He wrote that ‘the whole Narnian story is about Christ’. Lewis could not have been clearer.”
Mr Hooper attributed Neeson’s remarks to political correctness and a wish to be “very multi-cultural”.
And that’s saying it nicely. Others are being a little more blunt:
William Oddie, a fomer editor of The Catholic Herald and a lifelong fan of the Chronicles of Narnia, accused Neeson of ‘a betrayal of Lewis’s intention and a shameful distortion’.
He said: ‘Aslan is clearly established from the very beginning of the whole cannon as being a Christ figure. I can’t believe that Liam Neeson is so stupid as not to know.’
Amen. Let’s refocus on the Voyage:
Neeson did say that the Queen told him she cried at the film’s London premiere.
Oh, and I know where you can see an actual wardrobe from Lewis’ childhood home. Click here for more.
Naria quote to ponder:
‘If there’s anyone who can appear before Aslan without their knees knocking, they’re either braver than me or else just silly.’
‘Then he isn’t safe?’ asked Lucy.
‘Safe?’ said Mr. Beaver. ‘Don’t you hear what Mrs. Beaver tells you? Who said anything about safe? ‘Course he isn’t safe. But he’s good. He’s the King, I tell you.’























































































































Comments (352)
salvawhoray
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:38pmits real simple people just stop seeing his movies, hell just stop going to the movies period.
Read a damn book or go workout and lose some weight.
Report this comment
GingerB
Dec. 6, 2010 at 2:03pmWHO awrote this comment MICHELE OBAMA?
Report this comment
grandmaof5
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:37pmI didn’t think Muslims liked Mohammed or Allah being portrayed as anything, hence the uprising over the cartoon. I hope they chalk this up to stupidity on the part of Neeson and don’t get all huffy or violent about his comments.
Report this comment
roberja
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:33pmJc, this is not what the Word of God says. Oh, God is a just a movie and has nothing to do with what Jesus says. Jesus is the only one with an empty tomb. Aslan is Christ Jesus and none other.
Report this comment
pilgrim2497
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:31pmMr. Neeson’s comments are a huge betrayal of the genius and spiritual foundations of C.S. Lewis.
Report this comment
bobbezza
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:31pmI hope Liam is not infering that the lion is a picture of Muhammad..if so he may be TAKEN!!
Report this comment
guyperram
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:29pmNow don’t get your blood pressure up. Liam is a good actor, and that is what he should stay. Otherwise he is very prone to open his mouth and shoving his foot into it.
Report this comment
overlumber
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:25pmThere is no PC in the Narnian Chronicals – they are about what Lewis said they were about, nothing less, nothing more. They do not embody anything/body other than Christ and to say they do is an ignorant insult to both Christ himself and His devoted follower, C. S. Lewis.
Dialogue, of course, is always welcome in the pursuit of knowledge and wisdom; dialogue with troglodytes leads neither to knowledge nor to wisdom just as dialogue with those whose interest is the destruction of the foundations of Western Civilization is and will be forever futile.
Neeson is welcome to his interpretation of any of his screen parts no matter how far from the truth he may stray.
Report this comment
MAULEMALL
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:23pmGood…Gives me a reason not to take my ….
Eff amoe
Report this comment
nummy1
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:22pmI’d say it’s as much of an adult movie as a kids movie. But yes, I agree, let’s not try to change the meaning of what C.S. Lewis originally meant. No need to be PC with anything and everything.
Report this comment
J.C. McGlynn
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:21pmGeorge Burns: Oh,God II…. One of the last scenes…” I am Christ, I am Budda, I am Yahweh, and others. All people worship me in their own way.” To me, this makes the same difference.
Report this comment
firstHat
Dec. 6, 2010 at 11:03amWell, Lewis does do something similar with Aslan. Only when GOOD things are done in the name of Tash, do they become deeds done in the name of Aslan. It is NOT that Tash and Aslan are the same, it is that no good can be done in the name of the inherently evil Tash so that Aslan may lay claim to good done in Tash’s name.
Report this comment
tiredofdeception
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:21pmThe world has been sold a bad lie about the Islam. Hey, Liam, you like slavery? Do you think it is okay for girls under the age of 10 to be sold in marriage? Do you think hatred of all infidels is cool? Why would you embrace a religion that kills homosexuals? Mohammad and the word “children” should not be said in the same sentence as Mohammad was a pedophile. I find it ironic that progressives fight so hard for this religion and a political system designed to regress man back to the stone age. I am tired of Islam being shoved down my throat.
Report this comment
SlimnRanger
Dec. 4, 2010 at 1:08pmAman to that
Report this comment
megaman
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:21pmI dont believe Liam Neeson comment that aslan can resemble Mohamed or other prophets or Buddha. Aslan definably only resembles Jesus Christ in everything he does. like willing to die in Edmond place.
Report this comment
aicardi
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:20pmActors should keep their opinions to themselves. They seem to not be very bright just very entertaining. Anyone who has ever read the series knows that it is a Christian series and that Aslan represents Christ. Great actor trying to be pc… so sad.
Report this comment
TonyB_84
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:44pmSo, um, you should keep YOUR opinion to yourself then too? He can say what he wants and BELIEVE what he wants.
Report this comment
aLinedog
Dec. 4, 2010 at 1:00pmActually Tory, if one is incorrect in his beliefs he should be corrected immediately. Otherwise, you end up with a false religion spewing hatred, intolerance, and demeaning/lowering women. All the while advocating violence against non-believers and in a great charade accusing the same of being ‘evil crusaders’ bent on Islam’s destruction. Oh darn, outed myself.
Newsflash my muslim ‘friends’, if that day does come, you’re guarandamned right I’ll be a Crusader.
-line
Report this comment
MrButcher
Dec. 4, 2010 at 1:01pmright on, Tony!
Report this comment
MeteoricLimbo
Dec. 4, 2010 at 2:38pmwell put
Report this comment
tierrah
Dec. 4, 2010 at 3:09pmI think there is one point that hasn’t been made about “freedom” to speech. We all have that right by the Constitution, at least for now. There is an imbalance, to me, when someone of Mr. Neeson’s status speaks his opinions, all the world hears them. When you or I speak our opinion, only a few hear them. In controversial social issues such as religion, I think those of stardom should keep their mouths shut since everything they say and do is broadcasted to the nines!!
Report this comment
TonyB_84
Dec. 4, 2010 at 6:07pmWho’s to say his beliefs are wrong?? You? I believe that Aslan is Satan. Now what? I can see where Mr. Neeson is coming from. I’m not a Bible thumpin’ Christian who’s damning everyone to hell. That’s God’s job. Not mine. Remember, we’re talking about a fictional Lion here. Calm down and go have a Coke and a Smile.
Report this comment
Resolved
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:19pmIf Liam Neeson wants to see Aslan as representing any or all of the “great spirtual leaders” of our time, I guess that’s his right, especially since he qualified his statement “This is what Aslan means TO ME.” But C.S. Lewis made it pretty clear what the intent was, and like the story says, his death on the table pretty much solidifies the Christ metaphor. I could be wrong, but pretty sure none of the other spirtual leaders Neeson mentioned ever came back from death.
Report this comment
robert5635
Dec. 4, 2010 at 4:29pmMuch less ascended to heaven, to sit at the Right Hand of God, til He returns to claim His Children/Bride. Talk about a good day!
Report this comment
David Foxfire
Dec. 8, 2010 at 7:19pmThat’s right, Liam did qualify that, so what he said about Aslan being Mohammad, I’ll take it with the proverbial grain of salt. Preferably the low sodium kind.
Me? I’d like to see Mohammad get killed off by the Taliban and get up after a day or so. That’s pretty much what happened in the Passion Play. Or for that matter, Jesus pounding a Pharisee into pate, like what Aslan did at the end of “Lion Witch and Wardrobe.” I wanted the lion to just nom her myself.
(Personally, I could see Aslan having a part/several parts of Jesus, a part of Mohammad, a part of Bhudda, I can go on. But again, that’s just me.)
I’ll shut up now.
Report this comment
srmumz
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:18pmMr. Neeson is more than welcome to make the short 10 minute drive from his home to our non-denominational church where we would be more than willing to discuss Christian theology with him.
Report this comment
conservativejazzman
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:14pmWhat the hell?
Report this comment
T.E.A.PARTNER
Dec. 6, 2010 at 11:27pmActually you can find that place in ‘THE GREAT DIVORCE’. Hope it’s as nice as Neeson’s dreams.
Report this comment
navychick
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:14pmaslan is symbolic of Christ. Lewis would NEVER had it another way. I love this books and to have this cat say this about this caracter is disgraceful. HE SHOULD BE FIRED and all the movies redone. Neeson DOES NOT deserve this part. I hate the fact that he said this.
Report this comment
Silversmith
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:13pmAnother actor who speaks without thinking.
Report this comment
mrlogan3
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:46pmIt’s not just actors, J.K. Rowling did it too, declaring Dumbledore to be gay. I think things like this should be left to conspiracy theorists.
Report this comment
MrButcher
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:13pmi agree, snow.
this is silly.
Report this comment
sean_m.
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:12pmExactly. They’re not going to hear what Liam Neeson says anyway.
Report this comment
Paul Ryan for Pres
Dec. 6, 2010 at 7:47pmI’ve heard what he’s said and he’s wrong. There is nothing more important in my life than my walk with Christ. If that is not the case for you, imagine if what you held dearest in life (your mother, or child, or whatever) was continually slandered and denegraded and distorted. It gets old. If you have read the books (which I recommend because the movies have done them no justice) you would see the author’s intent on who Aslan represents: Christ. In “The Last Battle”, an ape spreads lies about Aslan and tells Narnians that he is one and the same as the god “Tash.” In fact, the Ape begins to decieve them by referring to the two beings as “Tashlan.” This is the great evil that C.S. Lewis portrayed so artfully. You don’t have to agree with either faith, but you are being decieved if you believe Christ Jesus and Muhumad are one and the same. I love his voice, but mabey they should have cast Nielson as the ape…
Report this comment
AlaskaRick
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:12pmAslan also symbolizes the Muslim Terrorist who in order to start winning wars again made up a lie that his men would receive 72 virgins if they died in battle? Seriously?
Report this comment
snowleopard3200 {mix art}
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:53pmAsland and the terrorist speak…
(Asland: “Burp!!!”
Update: No comments made on the disappearance of the terrorist, or of the suddenly bulging belly found on Asland.
Report this comment
CaptGregg
Dec. 4, 2010 at 1:26pmMay those 72 virgins have the beauty and charm of Helen Thomas.
Report this comment
King4wd
Dec. 4, 2010 at 5:54pmAs Achmed says- no one said those virgins were going to be girls!
Report this comment
JJ Coolay
Dec. 5, 2010 at 3:42am@ King….. That’s beautiful! What an awful surprise that would be! lol
Report this comment
GJPinks
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:12pmPerhaps someone might send the Narnia Collection to Mr Neeson. If that is to difficult, perhaps the Screwtape Letters.
Report this comment
Rn mom
Dec. 4, 2010 at 2:57pmExactly what I was thinking. C.S, Lewis is one of my favorite authors. I am sure Liam has come across the other works of C.S. Lewis, like Mere Christianity or Screwtape Letters. I think Neeson should have worked on Tolkien’s movies instead.
C.S. Lewis was an atheist who found Jesus, and his works were dedicated to that end. Liam should read the Bible and maybe the symbolism of C.S Lewis wouldn’t be lost on him.
Report this comment
King4wd
Dec. 4, 2010 at 5:09pm@RN MOM-
We’d have a similar result if Neeson had worked on the LOTR or Hobbit movies. Tolkein was the one who convinced C.S. Lewis to accept Jesus.
Aside from that, I find Liam Neeson to be an outstanding actor. He’s just doing the regular Hollywood thing and covering all PC bases. Coming out as a Christian can be hazardous to one’s career in Hollywood. Especially for supporting character actors like Neeson.
BTW if you haven’t seen it, check out A Prayer For The Dying. A highly under-rated IRA thriller from the ’80s with Liam Neeson, Mickey Rourke and Bob Hoskins.
Report this comment
SHOOTnCRASH
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:11pmI agree.
Report this comment
Star Spangled
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:11pmMr. Neeson is a fine actor , too bad he doesn’t understand the authors message .
Report this comment
navychick
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:16pmIsn’t a “good” actor suppose to understand the writer also not just the script. I am sorry but I have to disagree with you
Report this comment
Chet Hempstead
Dec. 4, 2010 at 1:51pmErnest Hemingway once said that a writer cannot write a character who is smarter than he is. Fortunately, this is not true of actors playing characters smarter than they are, or there would be almost no movies made anywhere in the world.
Report this comment
Taquoshi
Dec. 4, 2010 at 10:01pmSince I minored in Speech and Theater in college and spent an entire semester doing independent study on C.S. Lewis, I’m surprised that Neeson failed to comprehend that the actor’s job is to understand the author’s worldview and/or social framework in order to portray the character in the manner that the author created him/her. There are interpretations of how that character should be presented,(Clark Gable as Rhett Butler; Marlon Brando as Brick in A Streetcar Named Desire and many others that I could name who created unforgettable portraits of the characters) but the central core of who the character is must remain consistent in order to retain the identity of the character and the chemistry between the other characters in the play/book/poem.
I know we’ve seen lots of “adaptations” of classics into “contemporary” renditions, but most of the time, too much is lost in the translation. While some may see Captain Ahab as a Greenpeace activist, and Queequeg as a social commentator, it would totally destroy the story of Moby Dick. It may provide an interesting tale, and possibly one that was even entertaining, but it would cease to be Moby Dick.
Fortunately, it appears that Neeson only verbally expressed this. IMHO, Neeson not only totally missed the boat on this one, but possibly the dock and harbor by trying to incorporate things that Lewis never intended into Aslan. He may like his interpretation of the role as the god of the Buddists, Hindus, Muslims, anamists and what have you, but his personal interpretation sure ain’t Aslan. Maybe he confused Aslan with the role of the the giant polar bear Iorek Byrnison from the Golden Compass.
Report this comment
Lonescrapper
Dec. 5, 2010 at 9:16amHe probably hasn’t even read the book or about CS Lewis. Just a skimming over Lewis’s biography would have clearly indicated his story was meant to be an analogy – and his inclusion of Mohammad in a Christ analogy is as much an insult to Islam as it is to Christianity. So much for ‘inclusiveness.’
Report this comment
M31Sailor
Dec. 4, 2010 at 12:11pmGood thing Aslan wasn’t a dog , playing the role as Aslan. Billions of “Peaceful” musselmen would be rioting all over the planet. And Always listen to Mrs. Beaver
Sailor
Report this comment
untameable-kate
Dec. 4, 2010 at 1:16pm…or a pig.
Report this comment
MeteoricLimbo
Dec. 4, 2010 at 2:40pmhahahahaha@Kate!
Report this comment