Israeli-Americans’ U.S. Passport Case Against Obama Admin Goes to Supreme Court
Following President Barack Obama’s call for Israel to return to its 1967 borders, there has been much talk about his treatment of America’s greatest ally in the Middle East. Some accuse him of being anti-Israel, while claiming that his stances have irreparably damaged his support among American Jews.
Now, Obama faces additional scrutiny surrounding a battle over Israeli-American passports and the administration’s stance on Jerusalem. To add insult to injury, the fight is headed for the U.S. Supreme Court, where the president could face public defeat on the issue this fall.
The controversy can be summarized as follows: If an American citizen was born in Jerusalem, the United States government will not include “Israel” as the locality of birth on an individual’s passport. Considering the ongoing debate surrounding Jerusalem, this decision has purportedly been made to avoid inciting international anger among those who would dispute Israel’s ownership of the city. Some have called this move discriminatory, while others — mainly those in the executive branch — have defended it.
But, regardless of once’s stance on the issue, the time has come to conclusively settle the debate. The family of Menachem Zivotofsky, an American citizen who was born in Jerusalem in 2002, is taking legal action in an effort to change the U.S. State Department’s policy.
At the heart of this debate is a 2002 instruction to the State Department (within the Foreign Relations Authorization Act) by Congress. By law, the Department is required to record Israel as the place of birth on passports of American children who were born in Jerusalem, should parents request it. The New York Times sheds more light on the issue:
This fall, not long after Menachem turns 9, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in his case, which seeks to force the executive branch to follow the 2002 law. The case weaves together generations of conflict in the Middle East, the dueling roles of Congress and the president in the conduct of foreign affairs and the combustible topic of presidential signing statements.
Nathan Lewin, a lawyer for Menachem and his parents, said the point pressed in the lawsuit was a modest one shared by many people. “This client is representative of a large group of American citizens born in Jerusalem who are proud of the fact that they were born in Israel,” he said, “and they want their passports to reflect that fact.”
The Obama administration failed to convince the High Court not to hear the case. Additionally, the justices will force all sides to face the question of whether the contentious law “impermissibly infringes the president’s power to recognize foreign sovereigns.”
In the past, the courts have said that the president’s authority to “receive ambassadors and other public ministers” also means that he has the power to recognize foreign governments. Robert J. Reinstein, a law professor at Temple University, disagrees with this sentiment and claims that the president does not have the authority to recognize foreign states and governments.
President Obama isn’t alone in his efforts to avoid complying with the law. While it was signed by President George W. Bush back in 2002, Bush expressed his disagreement with its tenets and claimed that he would not necessarily comply with it. Perhaps Thompson Reuters best summarizes the presidents’ stance on the matter:
Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama say this unconstitutionally limits their powers, since U.S. policy for six decades has been to leave Jerusalem’s status to Israel and the Palestinians.
Groups like One Nation stand strongly against both presidents’ stances on the issue, but they particularly target Obama in their reaction:
This case is especially important at a time when the US President has effectively endorsed the division of Jerusalem in calling for a return to the 1967 lines while an overwhelming majority of Congress supports defensible borders and a united Jerusalem.
The debate over which branch of government has the authority to decide an issue like this will likely be settled this fall. It will be intriguing to see how both sides rationalize their viewpoints on the matter.
- Shock Video Surfaces: Meat Cleaver-Wielding Man Shouts ‘You People Will Never Be Safe!’ Moments After Gruesome London Attack 533 Comments
- Why Were DHS Agents Seemingly Monitoring Multiple Tea Party IRS Protests Across the Country on Tuesday? 468 Comments
- Confusion Erupts in IRS Hearing After Lois Lerner Tries to Plead the 5th — Watch It All Unfold 459 Comments
- The Tense Exchange Between Rep. Trey Gowdy and the Former IRS Head You’ve Been Waiting for…and It Doesn’t Disappoint 347 Comments
- CNN’s Wolf Blitzer Has Awkward Moment With Okla. Tornado Survivor After Asking If She ‘Thanked the Lord’ 326 Comments
- Beck Issues Challenge to People of Faith in Wake of Okla. Tornado: ‘What Have You Done?’ Read More
- ‘Islamic Jihad, Islamic Jihad!: Michelle Malkin Rips Progressives, Clashes With Lib Radio Host Over Islamic Terrorism and the London Machete Attack Read More
- Ariz. Lawmaker Surprises Colleagues, Comes Out as an Atheist While Delivering Daily Prayer Read More
- This Is How Texas Politicians Are Fighting Against the Atheist-Led ‘War on Christmas’ Read More
- ‘Unbelievable’: Apparent Thief Leaves $140 & Apology Note on Family’s Doorstep — Find Out Why Read More
- Weekly Unemployment Benefits Tumble Read More
- Why Is This German Company Recruiting Tech Staff With Autism? Read More
- House Votes to Speed up Keystone Pipeline: Here’s Everyone Who Voted for and Against It Read More
- Here are the 7 Most Explosive & Informative Moments from Today’s IRS Hearing Read More
- Foreign Banks Operating on U.S. Soil Have Just Set a Record Read More
- The Incredible Role Facebook Played in the Aftermath of Devastating Okla. Tornado Read More
- Tech Company Demonstrates Remote Disabling of a ‘Smart Gun’ 116 Comments
- Meet the Blind Man Nicknamed ‘Midnight Gunslinger’ Who Has 80% Shot Accuracy Read More
- How a $4.5 Million Network of 181 Sirens Helped Save Lives in Oklahoma Twister Read More
- See the Record-Setting Python a Man Caught With His Bare Hands (and Guess How Much It Weighed) Read More
- Socialists try to form new govt in Bulgaria
- Britain: Soldier slaying suspects had been probed
- Sorrentino serves up a cinema banquet at Cannes
- Stock slump continues on Wall Street
- Czech police seek US man suspected of 4 murders
- Ralph Lauren's 4Q profit rises 35 pct
- Taliban rickshaw bomb kills 13 in Pakistan
- UEFA introduces minimum ban for racist abuse