Town councilors in Windham, ME, are considering 14-year Sierra Yost’s proposal to ban all plastic shopping bags and charge 10 cents for paper bags.
“Inspired by a science class project on plastics, Sierra presented a proposal to the Windham Town Council on Tuesday to ban plastic bags and charge 10 cents for non-recyclable paper bags at the checkout counters of stores larger than 2,500 square feet,” the Kennebec Journal reports.
The town staff is writing up a draft of her proposal to present to the town council next week.
“They were really impressed with all the information I found,” Yost said.
Some of the council members are onboard with the proposal.
“There’s a lot of interest in it between the councilors. I don’t think it’s a bad idea,” Councilor Tom Gleason said.
Should the council adopt Yost’s proposal, Windham would be joining the ranks of a few other towns and cities in the U.S. that have passed similar anti-shopping bag laws.
“We would be the first town in Maine to put such an ordinance in place. Other towns would soon follow our lead — we would start a chain reaction,” Yost told the council during her presentation.
“Windham residents’ new mantra would be ‘Must remember reusable bags.’ With the average person using four to five bags per shopping trip, it would only cost 50 cents to buy paper bags — not enough to motivate people to shop in other towns, but just enough to kick the habit,” she added.
Although there’s already a statewide campaign in place for reducing the use of shopping bags, Yost doesn’t believe the effort to get people to cut back voluntarily has been effective.
“We have to go a step farther,” she said.
What’s slightly ironic about the proposal is that, according to the Kennebec Journal, Yost got the idea from a school project about the benefits of plastics.
“[S]he said it was what she learned about the negative impact that struck her most,” the Kennebec Journal’s Leslie Bridgers writes, “She said she learned that plastics break down into smaller pieces that can end up in the ocean and get eaten by animals, and also by humans.”
“That was a really scary thought,” Sierra said.
So the industrious 8th grader sprung into action. She started by calling stores in her town to ask them to stop giving customers plastic bags.
“They all said it was a corporate thing,” she said.
So she took the next step: she decided she would give the town council a presentation on the benefits of a bag ban/tax.
Her proposal, one that would affect stores with more than 2,500 square feet of retail space, “would completely ban the use of single-use plastic bags. Stores would be able to offer paper bags to customers for a 10-cent tax — 1 cent of which would be kept by the retailer — per bag,” according to The Independent.
While researching her presentation, Yost discovered similar bans passed in other cities and countries.
“In each case she presented, the imposition of a ban or tax on disposable shopping bags resulted in widespread adoption of reusable grocery bags within weeks,” The Independent reports.
“Yost said she estimated that, if her program resulted in 70 percent of shoppers using reusable bags, the tax on paper bags would bring the town about $90,000 in additional annual revenue,” the report adds.
And she gathered more data.
“The week before her presentation to the council, she was still collecting information. She put out a survey to Windham Middle School parents asking where they shop and what type of bags they use,” the report claims.
“More than half of the 60 people who responded said they use reusable bags — a figure that didn’t match the statistic she got from the local Shaw’s supermarket, which indicated that 85 percent of customers use plastic,” the report adds.
She included all the above in a fact sheet she gave to councilors during her presentation, which she said “went really well,” according to Bridgers.
The Windham town council is meeting next week to discuss the ban.





















































































































Comments (105)
Mainer forever
Apr. 18, 2012 at 9:26pmOhh My Gosh…this is happening right in my own town…..Yikes…..The plastic bags that are used at the local supermarkets are made out of cornstarch and break down in landfills easier than just plastic. Yeah…just what we need…MORE taxes!!! God Almighty…..paper bags for 10 cents? Does this kid know that paper is a renewable resouce?
Report this comment
howardroark1165
Apr. 18, 2012 at 8:25pm“They were really impressed with all the information I found,” Yost said.
That just proves that THEY are just as, if not stupider than YOU, you little Brown Shirt.
I live in Seattle, WA, a lib mecca where such plastic bag bans come around like clock work. What they don’t realize is that the plastic bags are bio degradable to begin with AND they actually take less energy and resources and break down faster than paper bags.
Not to mention the fact that I REUSE at least 2 and some times 3 per day when I following my Great Dane around.
At the grocery store there is a box out front where mis guided, well meaning people bring back their plastic bags. This works out great for me. Periodically I grab a huge pile of them to use in my K9 Fecal Collection program. Then, after collection, when possible I toss the bag and contents into someone’s Yard Waste container – I figure it came out of someone’s yard….. If he left the specimen on the side walk, I put the collected matter in someone’s Recycling bin since it didn’t come out of a yard.
Report this comment
another_mormon_4_Ron_Paul
Apr. 18, 2012 at 7:52pmI cut up plastic bags and crochet with them. What am I going to crochet with now? (Google “plarn”)
Report this comment
ripley
Apr. 18, 2012 at 1:56pmStupid idea. Send her to college & perhaps she can invent biodegradeable plastic bags. What’s next? Cloth garbage bags? Give me a break.
Report this comment
garylee123
Apr. 18, 2012 at 1:23pmWhy not spend her time finding a viable alternative to plastic bags or how to make them bio degradable. But no, insert yourself into the lives of others and tell them what to do. Next thing you know , they will be getting rid of light bulbs….oh wait.
Report this comment
AnAmericanToo
Apr. 18, 2012 at 12:52pmI have a friend who is retired from the waste industry. He has told me that the “plastic bags” are made of biodegradable material. They won’t last forever. (I do have concerns about the bags getting swallowed by animals or animals getting wrapped up and strangled in the bags).
Here is my take on this 14 year CHILD.. She had the moxie to call up adults and demand that they change their business practices. Wow! Then she decided to take her cause to the local government. She thinks it would be great to charge OTHERS since she is not self support ten cents per paper bag usage. Has she bothered to study the economic impact upon people with this?
Her solution appears to be cloth/reusable bags. Oh great! Has she compared the impact of cloth to plastic or paper bags? Cotton is raised on farm land (chemicals used to grow it??), spun in a factory (petroleum in the process); formed into cloth and made into a cloth grocery bag. The cloth bags are KNOWN to harbor nasty germs so they will need to be WASHED regularly — laundry soap, water, and possible time in the dryer. Some cloth bags have inked on slogans — what is in the ink?
I wonder if this girl would be willing to ban school buses in her community to contribute to saving the planet and her community? All kids would have to walk to and from school. (Think of the savings! no metal produced for buses, no tires from petroleum, no fuel usage, and a great financial savings to the community.)
Report this comment
Hephzibah
Apr. 18, 2012 at 11:35am“charge 10 cents for non-recyclable paper bags”
What makes paper bags “non-recyclable”? Is paper not recyclable? Weyerhaeuser plants thousands of acres of renewable trees. There are dozens of ways to reuse both kinds of bags. Instead of making new laws removing yet another freedom, we need to start parenting, teaching, disciplining, and fining for bad behavior.
If they want to ban something, I wish they’d ban that hard plastic packaging…you know, the stuff that amputates fingers when you’re trying to remove it from around the new product you bought.
Report this comment
G-WHIZ
Apr. 18, 2012 at 11:06amWhile your at it, why not get rid of all mechanically-driven vehicles and then live and breath all that beautifull horse-shitt-dust, an all that lovely slimey brownstuff all over your streets and walkways, to track into your horse-smelling homes and barns. Oh–yeh…The feds then will make it impossible to raise all that extra millions of tons of horse-hey you will need to feed them. How-’bout the hours-a-day needed to take care of them…no idle-time for computer-porn, crack-berries, texting,tweeting ,etc.No airplains or trains or tucks…just “hi-speed” horse-carts—WOW! Just think of horse-drawn oil-rigs, coal(brought-in by horse-cart)fired refineries…Hey what are you gonna use it for, oil-lamps and candles, or horse-driven electric-generation? Can y’all say…LOOOOSER! :O)
Report this comment
steve5150
Apr. 18, 2012 at 8:41amThis is a local town issue. If they want to ban plastic bags thats their choice. If it causes people to shop else where that is the shoppers choice. If they want to vote out the people who passed the ordinance that’s the voters choice.
Report this comment
asybot12
Apr. 18, 2012 at 8:12amOh and yes our so environmentally up to date council is going to force people to use water (we live in a semi desert area already on garden water restrictions) to clean food containers before recycling them !!!
Report this comment
beachmom
Apr. 18, 2012 at 7:28amI live in Maine and we do not have plastic bags flying all over the place.
This is just a publicity stunt. And a teen’s quest for her 15 minutes of fame.
By they way, we are on the move to the right here in Maine. We have, for the first time in over 40 yrs, have elected a Repub governor who has a spine and speaks his mind and we have a Repub majority in the state legislature.
Snowe is not running again. Too many of us have been confronting her on her unconstitutional votes.
Report this comment
G-WHIZ
Apr. 18, 2012 at 11:09amI sure HOPE sooo! Otherwise Y’all will be annother Frisco,Ca. Hahahahahahha! :o)
Report this comment
Mainer forever
Apr. 18, 2012 at 9:33pmHey ther Beachmom…which beach you at? My family has a place at Pine Point. Beautiful beach. Anyway…yes…about LePage…..I agree with him most of the time….I just wish he would practice what he is going to say a few times before he says it and mis speakes.. Anyway…all is well here in Windham…execpt for the soon to be 10 cent tax for using a paper bag. Take care
Report this comment
single stack
Apr. 18, 2012 at 6:44am“Although there’s already a statewide campaign in place for reducing the use of shopping bags, Yost doesn’t believe the effort to get people to cut back voluntarily has been effective.
“We have to go a step farther,” she said.”
My, what a good little statist.
If you can’t persuade people to go along with what you want use the power of government to force them.
Report this comment
Fourthhorseman
Apr. 18, 2012 at 6:43amit is a tax, nothing more. the council likes the 90k it will generate.
Report this comment
Bodysnatcher
Apr. 18, 2012 at 6:38amFirst they wanted to get rid of paper now plastic what is next
Report this comment
G-WHIZ
Apr. 18, 2012 at 11:13amThen they will “find-out” how many extra-special trucks to do pickup of all the extra-paper(tons) and “recycle” it. So they will, again, after spending all that lovely [not their money] will have to spend even more to re-instatute the “newest-thing”….plastic-bags… .WOW, who wouldda thought!
Report this comment
bigspike
Apr. 18, 2012 at 5:53am“She said she learned that plastics break down into smaller pieces that can end up in the ocean and get eaten by animals, and also by humans.”
“That was a really scary thought,” Sierra said.
====================================
actually, the thought of humans eating shopping bags isn’t scary; it’s called ‘natural selection’
Report this comment
lassiegirldawn
Apr. 18, 2012 at 4:05amDoes that go along with the douce bag politicisn
Report this comment
Salamander
Apr. 18, 2012 at 3:13amI can understand the survey discrepancy! I use ‘recyclable’ bags-the plastic ones get recycled as trash can liners in my home and the paper ones become the divider for separating my paper recyclables from my metal and plastic recyclables! Seems pretty green to me! I wonder if she has ever considered the filth introduced into a grocery store by people bringing in ‘recyclable’ bags? Maybe they run them through their washing machine after each use–now THERE is an energy saver–home wahed recyclables!
Report this comment
asybot12
Apr. 18, 2012 at 8:08amThe chemicals used in the cloth bags are there to prevent them from disintegrating them and from getting wet and soggy, the sad thing is that actually contributes to the rise in fungus and other potential poisonous infections such as e-coli and salmonella.
Report this comment
asybot12
Apr. 18, 2012 at 2:24amEarlier this year there was a study done in England that found that plastic in regards to cost to the environment taking into consideration cost of production, recycling longevity, and all other factors is 1/2 the cost of paper, 1/130 the cost of cloth!! And if you, like many people do, reuse plastic once even if it is for a kitchen garbage collection that cost goes down even further (you can’t use paper for wet garbage!!!)
The study also found that plastic decomposes faster than paper and way faster than cloth (BBC January 2012).
Report this comment
Honest_E
Apr. 18, 2012 at 1:20amI’m sick of my state being in the news for crap you would normally see coming out of California. This is everywhere.. they are pushing it on our kids in schools. My mom checked out Al Gore’s “Save the Planet” book for my kids and I pretty near blew a gasket. I asked her if she realized how much brainwashing propaganda was in his books and that he thought kids were “smarter than their parents”. She thinks I’m a nut – she also voted for his hein-ass.
Report this comment
Honest_E
Apr. 18, 2012 at 1:27amone would think it would be easier to recycle plastic than to recycle trees.. if this kid wants to save the planet one grocery bag at a time and make a name for himself, good for him. I just hope it’s not going to be state-wide.. i’ll drive the 20 mins to New Hampshire and give them my business.
Report this comment
bigspike
Apr. 18, 2012 at 6:01amsorry, but that’s the way Maine is; since the early 70′s, when there was a mass migration of burned-out NY and NJ hippies to New England, bringing their progressive agenda, the state has never been the same. the mantra then was ‘buddat’s not how we done it on lawnguyyyyyyyland’…when i returend from the Army in the mid-80′s, i found a state that was 75% Progressive and tilting ever further Left, and the economy was getting worse and worse…i spent 3 months trying to find a decent job and all that was offered was unemployment insurance…i ‘got while the gettin’ was good’…i took the last dollars in my pocket, bought a bus ticket to VA, and had a full-time job within 3 DAYS
Report this comment
Jenn of the Jungle
Apr. 18, 2012 at 1:07amThis is already in effect on many Californian towns….I know I live here.
Report this comment
Salamander
Apr. 18, 2012 at 3:14amMy condolences.
Report this comment
crazyrightwingmom
Apr. 18, 2012 at 12:56amBy the way, we have a dirty recycling plant near us in what used be a nice little community. Now everyone holds their nose as they go by. The roads are filthy, the air is filthy…trucks pull in and out, but oh, my, little squares of crushed paper get spewed out. Saving mankind!!
Report this comment
Salamander
Apr. 18, 2012 at 3:22amWow, JOBS! Sorting through all the misplaced recyclables! Nothing like a garbage-concentration facility to improve local real-estate prices! Wait until they have a fire–they tend to be very difficult to put out and stink like you cannot imagine! Go Green!. (Hey, in reality, I’m FOR green, but true green, not gore-green! True green evolves from free markets, so long as the life-cycle cost of a product is captured in the price! The fine-tuning and tweaking of miss-informed deliberative bodies, such as her town council, can make a mess of things! She should stop eating yoghurt because they put it in plastic containers! Don’t eat butter because they wrap it in waxed paper! No ice cream–what a waste of cardboard! No soda-waste of metal, glass and plastic! etc., etc., etc.
Report this comment