U.S. employers added only 96,000 jobs last month and the unemployment rate fell to 8.1 percent from 8.3 percent in July, the Bureau of Labor Statistics announced Friday morning.
What’s going on here? Is this a hopeful sign for the economy and the U.S. workforce? Well, not exactly.
First, it needs to be noted that unemployment fell only because more people left the workforce. Actually, a lot of people dropped out:
Labor force participation declined from 63.7 percent to 63.5 percent — its lowest point since 1981.
“It means that somehow in August the labor force declined by 368,000 people, which is a paradox since according to the household survey 119,000 jobs were lost in August, yet at the same time the unemployment rate dropped. Remember: it is an election year,” writers at Zero Hedge caution.
The next big thing that needs to be pointed out is that 9,000 of the 96,000 jobs added came from the resolution of a utility strike. Yep. Not new hires. Just people who decided to get back to work.
Next, Friday’s numbers are far, far below expectations. The BLS was hoping for at least 130K non-farm payroll jobs. Obviously today’s numbers don’t even come close. Private payrolls were also below the hoped-for estimate of 142K and settled at only 103K.
“This is very, very bad news for President Obama. It may even explain why he seemed kind of flat during portions of Thursday night’s speech, since I understand he knew the numbers at the time,” writes White House Dossier’s Keith Koffler.
And despite everything you have heard over the last three day from the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, N.C., U.S. manufacturing isn’t doing too well. A full 15K manufacturing jobs were lost last month, which, of course, makes President Obama’s recent promise of at least one million new manufacturing jobs by 2016 seem even more impossible.
“[W]hile the unemployment rate came lower (surprise, surprise: this is what appears in newspapers) at 8.1%, far lower than expectations of 8.3%, and below last month’s 8.3%, the broad total underemployment rate (U-6) continues to be sticky at 14.7%,” Zero Hedge notes.
Get that? Real unemployment (which counts those not looking for jobs) is actually at 14.7 percent.
The entire report is discouraging. Average hourly wages dipped a penny to $23.52 (and are only slightly ahead of inflation in the past year) and manufacturers cut the most jobs in two years.
Final Thought: Lousy hiring, declines in labor force participation, average hourly wages falling? Say hello to QE3. The Fed didn’t need much of an excuse to act and, if anything, this report just handed them one.
Also, as AEI’s James Pethokoukis notes, if labor force participation was the same in August as it was in July, these jobs numbers would mean an unemployment rate of 8.4 percent.
Follow Becket Adams (@BecketAdams) on Twitter
The AP contributed to this report. Front page photo courtesy the AP. This story has been updated.




























































































































Comments (57)
coalfired
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:25pmIs anyone talking about what they plan to do to bring manufacturing companies back to the US?
What are the plans to keep companies here, and help them expand?
For the past 3 and a half years, everything has been about how to restrict,add taxes and regulate them out of the country. The only job growth has been in government jobs. (union, of course) I wonder if anyone on the left has ever read any books other than Saul Alenski’s trash!
There needs to be a general blood letting throughout the established bureaucracies. In general, they are way more hindrance than help!
Report this comment
Gold Coin & Economic News
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:53pmBut everything is okay because our Dear Great Leader Obama will solve it all as in this selected reading of his DNC speech:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QecoDSOHkbk
Report this comment
TheMajority
Sep. 7, 2012 at 2:18pmYou have heard of redistribution, right? Well, in 1978 china decided to give “semi private business” a try. The first “rdistiributive trade agreements” were written under the Regan administration. It was called NAFTA. Ross Perot warned us against signing such agreements, but Clinton signed it, and repealed the glass stegal act, which kept wall street in check after the first depression. Every president since Clinton has signed more and more redistributive trade agreements, and here we are.
All we have to do is make the USA the most attractive nation to so business in, and they don’t have to come back even—-because we will build this place again no matter what.
The left has taught us that “part of Capitalsim is to find ways to make the product as cheap as possible, so trading massivly with communist china reall is Capitalism. Wrong folks, this is International redistirbution, and much like sharia (sp) law not being compatible with our Constitution, Capitalism is not compatable with communism.
communists will bring some back, we will not be able to start out own, and it will be dirt cheap labor. Won’t those “cup stacking kids” be real fast on the assembly line?
It is time us Citizens, reclaim ownership of our Capitalsism. Because when the government runs the economy, it is then called communism.
Report this comment
Chrison
Sep. 7, 2012 at 3:11pmCoalfired: One of the main reasons companies move their manufacturing out of the US is because of overly restrictive Government regulations (read EPA and Dept. of Labor to name a few) making it more difficult to operate. Romney/Ryan have said they will work to reduce the regulatory burden placed on business, including manufacturing, to make it more attractive to start new business and keep existing businesses in the US.
One of the main reasons businesses that have operations abroad keep their money abroad is because the current tax code penalizes them if they bring foreign profits home. Companies operating abroad pay corporate taxes in the countries where they operate. Currently, they then ALSO pay US corporate taxes on those same profits if they reinvest them back in the US. Therefore, there’s NO incentive for those businesses to bring foreign profits back to the States to invest here!
Romney/Ryan have said they will fix that problem so that companies are NOT taxed twice when they repatriate foreign profits so that they can invest in American jobs.
Are these two plans perfect? Far from it! But, at least it’s a start! With the current Administration, the “plan” is to raise taxes on those who create jobs and increase Government intervention in the economy. Thanks, but NO thanks!
Report this comment
Shiroi Raion
Sep. 7, 2012 at 4:26pmI thought it was bad before, but this is worse than I thought it was. We had about 67 million working and, aside from the slight return between 2003 and 2006, it’s been almost all downhill from there. Less than 64 million people in the workforce for the first time since 1983 and in 1983 we had about 40 million fewer people in the U.S. That is horrific! What has been the most drastic change that could have caused this? Big government and over-regulating are probably our biggest problems now and Obama has doubled down – tripled…
Also, if it comes down to deciding which direction to go – Progressive Left or Tea Party Right? I’m with the Tea Party. Going too far Left could cause irreversible damage, but it’s easy to reverse any damage that might be caused from a government that is too small. The government is always willing to grow and take more from the people, but when the big government becomes too big, they will refuse to give up power and they become increasingly corrupt and dishonest.
Report this comment
badge02812
Sep. 7, 2012 at 5:36pmDid anyone see the this Dumbocrats speech ???
Worth watching here …..http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKux363Dg64
The only thing missing from her speech was the HEIL OBAMA !!!!
SIEG HEIL OBAMA !!!
SEIG HEIL OBAMA !!!
SEIG HEIL OBAMA !!!
Report this comment
cookcountypatriot
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:12pmand suddenly a new idiot appears….it was delicious watching grandholm go howard dean last nite…lil mama dean proved that progressives trully are INSANE!
Report this comment
AvengerK
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:22pmHoward Dean has a new contender for liberal idiot extraordinaire.
Report this comment
SCREW-WINDOWS
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:23pmGranholm is well versed in how to fudge the truth and numbers.
Report this comment
vbell
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:11pmIf the labor participation rate is down to 63.5%, would that not make the ‘real’ unemployment rate at 36.5%.
Report this comment
V-MindMeld
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:08pmLooks like more of obamas fuzzy math,,,,,,im sure he will be bragging about the slight drop……which is another lie and distortion of the truth…….as always from his cronies
Report this comment
Sy Kosys
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:08pmA little OT, but found this while looking up “burger flippers” lol
A long read, but very insightful
http://www9.georgetown.edu/faculty/viksning/papers/reaganomics.html
“Hindsight enables us to say quite clearly that the economy’s productivity and efficiency were greatly improved by the Reagan years, and continue to provide the basis for the functioning of the economy well into the 21st century.”
Report this comment
JohnyQ
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:06pmLiberals and there delusions , no way can they be separated. Vote GOP Nov 2012
Report this comment
Rothbardian_in_the_Cleve
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:08pmThe GOP has blood on its hands. This isn’t all Obama. Far from it. If you think the Romney/Ryan plan (using a Ryan budget since Mitt hasn’t provided details) fixes this then you are sadly mistaken.
Report this comment
Chrison
Sep. 7, 2012 at 2:40pmRothbardian: The Romney/Ryan plan may not be ideal, but it’s a heck of a lot better than Obama’s plan. If re-elected, Obama will take MORE money out of the economy through the hidden taxes in Obamacare and the overt “make the rich pay” taxes. Once this money hits Washington, a huge percentage of it will be “skimmed” (i.e. wasted) before it’s “redistributed” back into the economy through handouts both to those in need and to the special interests.
The stark reality is that Government does NOT produce wealth, it merely consumes and redistributes wealth! Moreover, Government does NOT encourage independence and self-reliance, it stifles them!
I’d MUCH rather “take my chances” with the Romney/Ryan platform than continue down the current path of MORE Government intervention and control! Then, there’s at least a SLIM chance of halting the slow, grinding march of Government control over everything in America!
Romney/Ryan in 2012!
Report this comment
Bohump
Sep. 7, 2012 at 5:55pmJonnyq: ……. tell me about obomas,big plan…. Tax the rich,…. spend money ,.. print More money …spend it,… print more, … spend More …Give It to the Unions.. Take what you can get your hand’s on, .. Retire
Report this comment
thegreatcarnac
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:06pm“Here is what you need to know!”………………obama is killing this country.
Report this comment
Muckdog
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:49am“Shared prosperity!” Hey if the labor participation rate was lowered to 0, the unemployment rate would be 0%. Full employment!
Heckuva job, Barack.
Report this comment
TMunson
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:33amLets send this Administration to China a screw up their labor force and we might have a chance of creating some jobs here
Report this comment
stotlaat
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:31amclassic. Here was an attempt to codify deception in Oregon:http://oregoncatalyst.com/2467-OIA-alert-HB-2414-designed-to-mislead-voters.html where the legislature attempted to make voters say no to what they want and yes to what they reject. idiots in power = danger to everyone in their power
Report this comment
RodT82721
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:24amOur dear leader and his Chicago style administration are proving it’s a lot easier to eliminate a job then to help create one.
Their goal, and I expect they will reach it in their October surprise, is an unemployment number under that horrid 8%.
They have been adjusting the numbers for 3 years now, so they have become expert in getting the numbers they want. And they want an unemployment number under 8%.
The fact that the real unemployment number is 15% or more is not important, what’s important is what the media can report. No one will mention that this great employment success was brought about by getting rid of jobs.
If you don’t count them, they don’t count – Barry’s new campaign motto.
Report this comment
diskinetic
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:24amSo, if we destroy enough industries, then there will be fewer jobs to go around, and all those jobs will be filled, and you’ll have 100% employment!
Report this comment
frogg
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:20amObama continues to Lie at every turn. The Man couldn’t reconize the truth if it hit him in the face!
Vote the BUMS out this November! Please! Pretty Please!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Check out http://www.rescueourconstitution.com/
Report this comment
gunner1434
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:14amI love how the left use destorted data to try to make it seem like its not that bad. Haha, yeah, it may seem like unemployment rate droped, but what about the people that just gave up and started on welfare? When you see politicians use numbers, you know they are lying. Its to much of an opportunity to sway the sheep.
Report this comment
My Two Cents
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:23amObama is a genius. When the number of people who have dropped out of the workforce reaches 100% the unemployment rate will be 0%.
Report this comment
Rothbardian_in_the_Cleve
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:04pmOf course they did. How soon we forget Professor Mann and his little “trick” to create the hockey stick.
Report this comment
lisa2994
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:12amIt is way over 8% because they don’t count those no longer on unemployment nor those still looking for work. Twenty four million people unemployed the number is much higher than what we are being told. Last I heard it is more like 14%.
Report this comment
watersRpeople
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:22amThey also quite often do not count [part-time] employment when they count jobs added to the economy.
Report this comment
IMCHRISTIAN
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:09amWho ever authorizes a QE3 deserves to have their citizenship abolished. They could careless about our future or our kids and grandkids future. God Bless America.
Report this comment
watersRpeople
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:08amJust like Heaven and earth disappeared; just as a real true understanding of the Constitution has disappear – with all only the words remain. Likewise when one says “Collapse” it’s just a word without real meaning, and when people say “Massive inflation” it’s just a word without real meaning. The U.S is 1000 fold more complicated than it was even 40 years ago, let alone 70 years ago. I have neighbors selling their antique cars they rebuilt by hand; some neighbors have lost their homes; even other neighbors have cut back on lawn care expenses – inflation hasn’t even really kicked in yet. I feel comfortable saying that 80% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, and even for people living in households grossing 80,000 dollars per year. With the onset of massive inflation all those people will no longer be making it paycheck to paycheck anymore; won’t be buying as much gasoline; won’t be traveling to the mall to buy clothes as much. Additionally many of those people will be reselling much of the silver and gold they have purchased as they attempt to hold on. Now that 80% is dumb money, and they won’t be blowing their dough on all the companies that once thrived from them being loose with wisdom. That means many many businesses and individuals who once made 200,000 dollars per year won’t be making their standard of living either, and they will join the ranks of [paycheck to paycheck]. I guess what I saying is it’s more complicated than anyone can mentally conceive. It
Report this comment
booger71
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:28amBut the welfare kings and queens with still use their EBT cards to by smokes and alkeyhall
Report this comment
Master_and_Commander
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:07amOnce again, the numbers are being manipulated by the White House. So tired of the deception…
Report this comment
Rothbardian_in_the_Cleve
Sep. 7, 2012 at 12:06pmThey always have been. CPI has been revised three times since 1980. The birth death model gets tweaked continually. Owner Occupied Rent was added to BEA data.
This isn’t new. The ministry of truth knows no party.
Report this comment
jacobstroubles
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:03amHere’s What you Need to Know: They keep manipulating the numbers.. unemployment is way over 10%. He never speaks anything but double speak..he’s a liar. He said nothing at his speach last night. bill and joe were drunk on purple kool-aid. There was never anythreat of any such lighting storm at the outdoor arena..and the most horrific thing is that he’ll be in the wh come jan 20th 2013.
yup..regardless of all the lies and theft thus far.
Report this comment
usernametaken
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:00amGroundhog Day 2012
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=J5VMX2JahrU#t=0s
Report this comment
mersey
Sep. 7, 2012 at 10:58amThank God for McDonald’s! If it weren’t for the service industry progressives wouldn’t be able to find any work at all after graduation. Wake up Democrats, this in NOT the new normal….unless you re-elect this failure of a president.
Report this comment
Snowleopard {gallery of cat folks}
Sep. 7, 2012 at 10:52amFire Obama the failure and destroyer of our nation. He wants us to be communist; no way in my life and while I still draw air.
Report this comment
wboehmer
Sep. 7, 2012 at 10:50am96,000 net jobs for August
140,000 jobs needed to accommodate population growth
Shortfall = 44,000 jobs
Barack Øbama = the unemployment president steadily marching one-step-forward, two-steps-backward, hut . . . hut . . .
Report this comment
just the facts
Sep. 7, 2012 at 10:59amWhat’s equally as bad is the deception of the jobs to new claims. That ratio seems to be for every 1 job created, 2+ people are filing for a new unemployment claim. That info is not reported at all, at least not the way I would present it.
Report this comment
Tigress1
Sep. 7, 2012 at 10:48amFull employment in this country is around 4%. Right now it is 8.1%. There’s still a long way to go.
Has anybody seen any statistics on the TYPE of jobs that people who actually found jobs were located? I heard that food service jobs (McDonalds anyone?) were up by 25%. College students, how’s that hope and change? I bet you all planned on going to college so you could work in a fast-food restaurant! Are you lovin’ it yet?
Report this comment
Gonzo
Sep. 7, 2012 at 10:38amHere’s What you Need to Know: Obama is in way over his head and nothing he has tried has worked. He doesn’t have a clue how to fix it and it’s time for a CHANGE in the White House.
Report this comment
booger71
Sep. 7, 2012 at 11:30amsure he knows Gonzo, we just need more government “investments”
Report this comment
topperj
Sep. 7, 2012 at 1:45pmI respectfully disagree. I believe this is the outcome Obama wanted. His goal is the destruction of the US economy, our energy production and successful businesses. He has been quite clear about his dislike for the free market and the producers. He hates so-called fatcats, except when he needs their money, he hates business, except when he needs their support and money, he hates the military, he hates big oil companies, and on and on. So he is succeeding but it’s not the kind of success America needs.
Report this comment