Following the controversy surrounding Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney’s claim that 47 percent of Americans will vote for President Barack Obama because they’re dependent on government, Rep. Charlie Rangel (D-NY) on Tuesday released the following statement [emphasis added]:
“Rangel to Romney: Americans Pay Their Fair Share Of Taxes, Unlike You”
Nothing can be further from the truth than Gov. Romney’s ridiculous remarks that nearly half of American people do not pay federal income taxes, they pay other federal and state taxes. The 47 percent figure cited by the Republican presidential candidate covers only the federal income tax and ignores the fact that people may pay a higher percentage of their income on a wide variety of taxes.
Everyone pays taxes. Lower income persons pay state and local, property, excise and sales taxes. In fact, when all federal, state, and local taxes are taken into account, the bottom fifth of households pays about 16 percent of their incomes in taxes, on average. The second-poorest fifth pays about 21 percent. This is higher than what the Governor has paid in income taxes. He has absolutely no moral authority to accuse nearly half of the American people of being irresponsible and freeloaders.
Many of his millionaire and billionaire friends — approximately 55,000 — are paying lower taxes than millions of middle-class Americans. In fact, in 2009, 1,500 millionaires managed to pay no federal income taxes on their millions. Before he judges other people about paying federal income taxes, Gov. Romney should come clean about the tax returns he’s hiding from voters.
“Moral authority”? See, this statement is funny when you consider the fact that Rep. Rangel has been censured by Congress for a number of tax and ethics violations. In fact, he’s been in hot water for a lot of violations.
We were going to put together a comprehensive list illustrating this point, but it looks like Mary Katharine Ham over at Hot Air has beat us to the best ones.
Let’s run through some of them, shall we?
Rep. Charlie Rangel amended his financial disclosure forms under pressure in 2009 to show “that he had omitted an array of assets, business transactions and sources of income. They include a Merrill Lynch Global account valued between $250,000 and $500,000; tens of thousands of dollars in municipal bonds; and $30,000 to $100,000 in rent from a multifamily brownstone building he owned on West 132nd Street.” That wasn’t all. “The latest filings come on top of an amendment to Mr. Rangel’s 2007 disclosure form reported this week showing that he had failed to list at least $500,000 in assets.” The new disclosures doubled Rangel’s net worth.
Rep. Charlie Rangel rented several apartments in Harlem at suspiciously below-market rates from a big campaign donor, combining several to create his home while using one of them as a campaign office. That was a violation of rent-control laws, which require rent-controlled apartments to be used as residences.
[…]
Rep. Charlie Rangel failed to report $75,000 in rental income or pay taxes on a Dominican villa he owned, causing the New York Times to call for him to step down from his Ways and Means Chairmanship.
[…]
Rangel is one of the most demonstrably corrupt manipulators of the tax code in Washington, and his longtime position as the guy who wrote tax code for the rest of us makes the corruption all the more despicable.
And there’s much, much more where that came from.
The point is this: if you want to lecture someone on not paying their “fair share,” it kinda’ helps if you don’t have a storied and illustrious past of possible criminal withholding.
Follow Becket Adams (@BecketAdams) on Twitter
Front page photo source courtesy the AP.





















































































































Comments (80)
denkat56
Sep. 21, 2012 at 12:37amhow in the world is romneys tax payments anything to be brought up. just shut up and man up and pay your taxes. and just figure your not part of the 48 percentile. dumba##.
Report this comment
Wayner
Sep. 21, 2012 at 1:00amI can understand that 47% don’t know about how crooked and corrupt Charley Rangel is because they’re the 47% that Romney was talking about who just don’t care and are too lackadaisical to come out of their crack induced stupor to know anything but to check the mail for the check.
Report this comment
designbyinspiration
Sep. 21, 2012 at 2:51amWould all you proggie wankers just shut the hell up about ‘Fair Share ™”. We ALL know it’s just another set of empty words you losers use as levers to pry our earned value away from us. I WILL NOT COMPLY!
You commies are becoming increasingly irrelevant, and I hope you saturate D.C. with your absence.
Report this comment
PATTY HENRY
Sep. 21, 2012 at 2:55amI know that most LIBERALS are cheats and liars but they need to understand that we are NOT. Who in their right mind would believe that MITT ROMNEY, in the finance business to begin with, would not have his tax obligations in tip-top shape??? HOW silly they are. That’s their problem tho’ they can’t understand that not all people are as dirty as they are.
Report this comment
JokerWatcher
Sep. 21, 2012 at 3:52amHypocrisy is the state of promoting or administering virtues, moral or religious beliefs, principles, etc., that one does not actually have or is also guilty of violating…Wikipedia.
the hypocrisy of the left, and now democrats in general, knows no bounds. They’re nuts! They’re notoriously uncharitible and cheap, lack self-motification (except when seeking asssitance). They loath entrepreneurs because self-made individuals shows their lack for what it is. How could anyone associate with such a disgusting party as represented by Rangel? It’s like proudly associating with pimps.
Report this comment
johnpaulkuchtajr
Sep. 21, 2012 at 6:00amFear not, conservative compatriots!
The time for all these worthless bastards to honor themselves is soon drawing to a close.
The Kenyan will soon be sharing a cell in federal prison with his AG, Harry Reid will be running the prison library and Nancy Pelosi will be housed in the women’s annex.
They’ll all look better in orange.
Report this comment
000degrees
Sep. 21, 2012 at 6:33amcharlie was not thrown into jail for these violations due to the fact that he is in “the club”…although he belongs in jail..
Report this comment
kettererbg
Sep. 21, 2012 at 7:00amWhat a bag of crap. This pus bag shouldn’t even be on the hill. Tells volumes about the idiots that elected him.
Report this comment
bplumb23
Sep. 21, 2012 at 7:08amI agree! But that’s the same thing if not worse than yelling about birther crap!!
Don’t you guys get it. Romney and Ryan and their Chiefs of Staff have done enough to kill us this time around, and my fellow Republicans are out yelling about birth certificates, homosexual comments, calling the President a socialist, blah blah blah.
Fine, believe what you will, but learn how to include people and get a vote movement going.
The ONLY way we win this is if more Republicans vote
There is NO SUCH THING as an undecided voter this year, I don’t buy it.
Stop the hate and let us win an election so we can make the change we all say we want.
WISE UP
Report this comment
ishka4me
Sep. 21, 2012 at 10:19amPet peeve that bothers me; the Democrats confusing cap gain tax with income taxes. Yes Romney paid 15% cap gains tax but had no income but he already paid taxes on this same money at least once. Now my parents live off of their Ira savings and any increase in the cap gains would kill them. Why our candidates do not put the tax and spend commies in their place drives me nuts. Most of us will someday cash in our ira savings and a large cap gain tax would kill us also. Think this is an argument we could destroy them on, but nobody does, they just let democrats win
Report this comment
turkey13
Sep. 21, 2012 at 11:51amAt least Romney paid his taxes! Congress could have passed a new law back in 2009 when they had the control of both houses and a Democratic president. Tthey chose to leave the Capital Gains tax at 15% for those that do pays taxes. Nancy Polisie and John Carry loved it and left it for their own benefit. Nancy was going to drain the swamp until Rangle, and 6 Szars that had to decline Obama because they owed the IRs. Turbo Timmy blamed his owed taxes on Turbo Tax. Nancy couldn’t get that plug back in fast enough, so the swamp didn’t get drained.
Report this comment
Wartface
Sep. 21, 2012 at 6:13pmHey Charlie Rangel… You are a crook and the only reason you’re not in jail is because your party had a super majority control of Congress and they let you off.
Also Charlie your party had the trifecta control of the United States government for 2 years and I notice you didn’t change the tax code to FORCE the rich to pay more. You just want to help the Kenyan get reelected.
Report this comment
pbrenda51
Sep. 23, 2012 at 3:00pmRomney is paying hisLEGAL share according to the law……so, apparently I am supposed to be upset about how Romney spends HIS money but now how Obama spends OURS????? I think I got it…..
Report this comment
For my Liberty!
Sep. 21, 2012 at 12:35amOK Charlie ole buddy…….then IF you want to go by YOUR figures…..Between the STATE and FEDERAL I DO PAY..and the REST of the CRAP that you added in that people pay that DO NOT PAY STATE and FEDERAL INCOME…I am paying between 66% and 71% of my income….I DO NOT get a refund…and I am SICK of being TERMED “RICH” at the Over 250K bracket because I am a SMALL BUSINESS …..I AM NOT “Rich” and I am SICK of the REDISTRIBUTION that your man is doing! IF you want to SUCCEED….WORK AT IT!
Report this comment
ScottG-CO
Sep. 21, 2012 at 12:35amSo says Charlie the rental slum-lord of New York!
Unfreakinbelievable!
Report this comment
Female
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:56pmProjection: a term used to place your own belief system upon another
Mirroring: accusing another of what you actually are guilty of doing
“1/2 Americans irresponsible and freeloaders” I don’t recall those terms coming from Romney
Report this comment
bplumb23
Sep. 21, 2012 at 7:23amYeah.
…
He rounded up.
Romney messed up, and we all know it. Let’s stop making excuses and do something to get our fellow Republicans out to the polls. That is our only chance.
Report this comment
Wool-Free Vision
Sep. 21, 2012 at 9:14ambplumb23, go to hell, you lying shill. All anyone has to do is click your name to see your last 10 posts, and it becomes painfully obvious who you really are and what you are all about.
You are no Republican, you are a damned deceitful shill. Even the most lukewarm establishment RiNO on Earth couldn’t come close to being as negative and openly combative to Conservatism as you are. You absolutely reek of liberal deception. And I’m calling you out.
It is a fact that there are RiNO’s who would foolishly agree with you that Romney “messed up and we all know it,” there are also some who will agree with you that the birther issue is a red herring. And there MIGHT be a handful of moronic establishment jerks who would claim that Rand Paul is “hijacking my party.” But there is so much wrong with your vociferous negativity in trashing Rush, Hannity, Coulter, Ingram, Brown, and your purported “fellow” Republicans, all while claiming that “the GOP is not inclusive enough,” that Romney is somehow “unelectable,” that the Romney/Ryan campaign “has done enough to kill us this time around,” that calling the prez a socialist is somehow wrong and unacceptable to you, and finally that “the whole beer vote aspect actually matters.”
It becomes PAINFULLY obvious that you are absolutely FULL OF FECAL MATTER. Please take your deceitful ways and shove them up your liberal access point. Tell MediaMatters that they are wasting their money on you.
Report this comment
Wool-Free Vision
Sep. 21, 2012 at 9:41amOne correction to my rant: it wasn’t Rand Paul whom you told to “stop hijacking my party,” it was a concerned Conservative who voiced the following opinion of Ron Paul:
“This jackass will throw us all under the bus to try and keep his name in the national discussion. I agree with some of his politics but damn, its time to get the hell out of the way and allow us to rescue this country! IMPEACH THE MUSLIM OBAMA NOW!!! WAKE THE HELL UP AMERICA!!!”
You call him a moron and tell him to “stop hijacking my party.” Meanwhile, you spew nothing but spite and venom at Conservative opinion from one side of the tent to the other, and you claim that WE somehow are the ones not being inclusive enough. Unbelievable!
Romney isn’t perfect, but he certainly isn’t “unelectable” by any stretch, and he certainly hasn’t “done enough to kill us this time around.” You contradict yourself over and over, both on the spirit of what you’re saying and in the letter of what you’re saying. You’re so busy being negative to every position that you leave yourself no place to make a stand on a firm principle.
If you dispute my accusations, then please enlighten us all as to what it is that you actually stand FOR. Tell us, what principles do you hold that make you a Republican. Because the only things I can see that you support by your last 10 comments are beer and veterans. What American DOESN’T support our veterans??????
Report this comment
Fatheroftwo
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:55pm“He has absolutely no moral authority to accuse nearly half of the American people of being irresponsible and freeloaders.”
Now that’s irony coming from an irresponsible freeloader!!!
Report this comment
Warriorswife
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:55pmCheaters believe that everyone cheats them. Liars believe that everyone is lying to them. Imagine the mind tricks poor Charlie plays on himself every day.
Report this comment
PATTY HENRY
Sep. 21, 2012 at 3:00am@ WARRIOR’S WIFE…. YOU said this so much better than I did. I never used to know this about Liberals, but it has become so clear to me now. THEY can’t believe in the GOOD of AMERICA because they aren’t good. etc. THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT point for us to remember and when we get our COUNTRY back, we have to address this, getting GOD back in Schools, (and everywhere) and getting the COMMIES and MIS-information out of our history books in schools.
Report this comment
KINGRUDDY
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:54pmSo Funny, I forgot to laugh…..Insulting to have to listen to this career criminal….the fact that he even has a platform to say anything. He should be laughed at….he should be shunned…..he should be ignored…he should be unemployed….He MOCKS all of us daily.
Wake up America!!!!
Report this comment
BODYBAG
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:38pmPost the video of Charlie bawling at his censure hearing admitting he’s
a crook and peeing his pants over the possibility he’ll get booted from
his cush lifetime tenure in the gov’ment.
Report this comment
crusaderx9
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:54pmhttp://www.nypost.com/p/news/national/charlie_unveils_his_crying_shame_1AIyjXlZWpVHmCxa8u4nrN
Maybe Bawney Fwank gave Tax Cheat Rangel a hug…
Report this comment
Chancellor
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:35pmThis is another misdirection attempt by the Compulsive Liar and his cast of clowns……
Can’t have the voters asking hard questions about the Economy, average 4.00 a Gallon gas, inflation or God forbid 16 TRILLION DEBT!
No no no….. Trot out one of the minions and have them read a prepared lie so everyone will scream and post about that. Heck Rangle isn’t even in the top 10 of biggest crooks from the DNC or NY!
Report this comment
DarkJello
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:41pmRangel should NOT lecture a cockroach about taxes! But is that fair to cockroaches.
What a joke of a statement by Range. I bet he has a warm greeting in the next life.
Report this comment
jvrat
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:32pmhow does gov get stuck with junk -lame free loaders -Charley clown?
Report this comment
Exrepublisheep
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:38pmRepublican running on family values platform caught hiring hookers, gets re-elected. (Vitter)
Report this comment
jvrat
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:25pmPilfering garbage has no voice
Report this comment
Wool-Free Vision
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:24pmThat Rangel, he is a laugh a minute. Much like Biden, he brings us Conservatives far more joy than he brings his own party. I bet the dems are all slapping their foreheads and wiping tears of frustration every time he opens his mouth, while the rest of us are slapping our knees and wiping tears of laughter. Oh, irony, thy party is Democrat.
The party of Charlie “Moral Authority” Rangel, Joe “Stand Up, Chuck” Biden, and let’s not forget Hank “Guam could tip over and capsize” Johnson. I could go on and on but laughing makes it hard to type…
Report this comment
Salamander
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:23pmThis guy is as dumb as a box of rocks! “In fact, in 2009, 1,500 millionaires managed to pay no federal income taxes on their millions.” Hey, dumba$$, it’s an INCOME tax, NOT a WEALTH tax! Your inflamatory and misleading statement makes absolutely no sense whatsoever! The only thing that scares me more than you is the people who elected you to office!
Report this comment
Psychosis
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:23pmthe bottom fifth of households pays about 16 percent of their incomes in taxes, on average. The second-poorest fifth pays about 21 percent. This is higher than what the Governor has paid in income taxes.
HE IS LYING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HE IS COMPARING collective of taxes to ONE tax , adding up the percentages and saying SEE he pays less, while IGNORING that adding up all the taxes payed by the wealthy in a similar fashion would add up to OVER 50%
this is par for the mathematically deficient democraps
Report this comment
Watermain
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:22pmWhy not Mr. Rangel, you crook? Half of America IS on the dole and I am sick of paying them. You want them on the government teat to keep getting their votes. You disgust me.
Report this comment
jvrat
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:22pmThis charley piece of dirt has been in our feedbag with an angle of rangle. A clear fool as a slap in the face to blacks that gained position because of jerks that believe in quotas ahead of merit
Report this comment
HKS
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:05pmThey don’t get any more crooked than this one, I’m certainly not impressed by anything he has to say.
Report this comment
PIGSWILLNEVERFLY
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:21pmHow many people know that Charles D. Rangle is a long time member of the Trilateral Commission?
http://www.augustforecast.com has a list of the 2008 member of David Rockerfeller and Zbegniew Brzezinski’s Trilateral Commission…an off shoot of the (CFR) Council on Foreign Relations.
There is also an article under white-papers catagory re: global banks embrace islam from 12/12/07!
Report this comment
BlackCrow
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:57pmSome of us do have a memory Charlie. Besides all you have done in the last 60 years has been use your office to enrich yourself. You Congressman Rangle are the very face of graft and corruption and the reason for term limits!
And you have the cahones to call Romney out on paying taxes? I think I’m going to heave!
Report this comment
barber2
Sep. 20, 2012 at 11:10pmBLACK : I know the one that we should heave. Racist ? No. Rational and Functional better describes what we should do .
Report this comment
nobull14
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:57pmCharlie Rangel should have been given a jail cell a long time ago .
Report this comment
barber2
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:56pmRangel is just a Democrat parrot who would be in jail if it were’t for the coverage of the Race Card that the Democrats have used for years to cover their illegal actions. Straw men wrapped in Red herrings ! Our New Far Left Democrats. Truman and JFK must be twirling. ROMNEY / RYAN 2012
Report this comment
USA DJ
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:55pmCharlie should have been sent to jail for his crimes. Just another example of the arrogance of the left where they really think they are above the rest of us and the rules don’t apply to them. Mitt Romney has built his fortune from hard work and intellegence. Unlike Charlie, he has built his career on lies and distortion.
Report this comment
dickdastardly
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:52pmCharlie the Cartoon…what a laugh…he’s lucky that Nanct Pelosi is around…she makes him look less mookish…but not by much
Report this comment
woodyee
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:49pm“Crooked Charlie” Rangell?
Where does an illiterate who went into the Congress a PAUPER get the millions in net worth he has today?
The answer(s) to THAT is more important than getting Romney to cough up tax returns and more worthy than a slanderous demand he pay his “fair share” coming from a DemonicRat Tax Cheat.
Report this comment
oldasdirt
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:57pmRep. Charlie Rangel and many other Democrats have done very well from just being in politics for life.Their children will do just fine. Will yours?
Report this comment
Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:58pmA crooked Congressman from Harlem? Hahh, couldn’t happen.
Report this comment
Netsurfer2
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:48pmWouldn’t be nice if they created a fair tax system where everyone paid the same on every dollar that they made??? Brackets just don’t make sense, nor show any sense of being fair!
I say “close the loop holes”, create a across-the-board fair tax system and audit the Fed!
That is the only way things can work!
I say Obama 2016 and it is very precise about what his agenda really is! “Being dependent on the government!”
Report this comment
Sirfoldallot
Sep. 20, 2012 at 10:47pmC. Ranel , lol now thats is the kettle called black, idiot.
Report this comment