
U.S. President Barack Obama greets doctors in the Rose Garden following an event at the White House on October 5, 2009 in Washington, DC promoting his health care plan. (Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images).
The 15-member Independent Payment Advisory Board (i.e. the so-called “death panel”) included in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”) has run into a bit of problem: Very few want to join.
Jonathan Gruber, for example, helped lay the groundwork for Massachusetts’ health-care law and played an important role in making “Obamacare” the law of the land. So you’d think he’d be an obvious choice for the panel, right?
“No way,” he said, according to the Washington Post. “Maybe if it was a part-time gig. But full time? I can’t see it.”
And he’s not alone.
“It is supposed to be 15 members, with limited salaries who can’t do any outside work,” former director of the Office of Budget and Management under Obama Peter Orszag said. “It will be challenging to find top 15 health-care experts are who would want that job.”
“You’re joining an organization that has uncertain authority with the certainty of being deeply political and widely criticized,” said former Obama health policy adviser Bob Kocher. “It doesn’t make sense for current thought leaders in American health care to want this.”
The creators of “Obamacare” claim the board’s chief purpose is to keep the cost of Medicare in check by changing the amount of Medicare’s doctor payments (in the past, these changes have been left up to legislators). And it’s because the panel has the power to amend these payments while also coming up with new ways to “deliver high quality care for less,” as the WaPo puts it, that critics of the law claim it will lead to rationed medicine.
“The Independent Payment Advisory Board brings unpredictably and uncertainty to providers,” said Rep. Allyson Y. Schwartz (D-Pa.). She favors doing away with the board altogether.
Perhaps one of the reasons the Obama administration is struggling to find people to lead the board is because the process involved in becoming a member if fairly grueling: You have to first qualify and then you have to make it through the confirmation hearings.
“It’s not only the challenge of finding people who will serve but also people who will serve and can get confirmed by the Senate,” said Harvard professor John McDonough.
Furthermore, as laid out in the healthcare law, board members will be “individuals with national recognition for their expertise in health finance and economics, actuarial science,” and related medical fields. Members will serve six-year terms and during that time they are prohibited from participating in “any other business, vocation or employment.”
So what happens if the Obama administration goes forward with implementing “Obamacare” and they still haven’t found anyone to head the board? The WaPo explains:
IPAB seats unfilled by blocked confirmations or a lack of interest, the Affordable Care Act includes a fallback measure. Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius has the authority to produce her own set of cost-cutting measures. Like those of the IPAB’s, they would also take effect automatically should Congress not pass an alternative.
Yes, if the administration finds it cannot staff the panel, its duties and power will be temporarily transferred to the Secretary of Health and Human Services.
“They’ll find people,” said Jonathan Gruber. “There are many who are, no doubt, very qualified. But I think they’ll miss out on a number of the very best.”
Click here to read the full report.
Follow Becket Adams (@BecketAdams) on Twitter
Featured image courtesy the Associated Press.























































































































Comments (120)
watashbuddyfriend
Jan. 29, 2013 at 8:39amMy Living Will is specific in that if I become unable to take care of myself, in any way, form, or fashion, from a disability, my doctor(s) are to apply eunathasia, to avoid pain, and suffering, and running up the financial tab by doctors, and hospitals! But, there is a problem, my doctor(s) hands are tied, by law, unless I move to Oregon. So, my take is that we need a Universal Law that will allow me, or anyone, to make the choice, in writing, to avoid the pain, suffering, and financial rendering by doctors, and hospitals.
Report this comment
Watcher1952
Jan. 29, 2013 at 8:35amI will serve on the board and my number one person to put down would be Barack Hussein Obama for lack of a properly functioning brain
Report this comment
nilo
Jan. 29, 2013 at 8:23amThat shouldn’t be too hard. There are a lot of people who have no morals / respect for life. If they can kill the unborn, they can kill the old with equal disregard.
Report this comment
americangrammy
Jan. 29, 2013 at 2:14pmThey are already killing off the old. Almost no DR will fight for the life of an old person anymore. The medical system has been preaching this for almost 40 years now. The very FIRST thing a DR will try to do when someone over 70 comes in to a hospital is try to talk the family into a NO CODE agreement. They don’t ask the patient, they ask the family even if the patient is awake, aware and coherent. We went through this when my mom was hospitalized. Several of the doctors did their best to intimidate and coerce us into signing what is literally a death warrant. We had asked my mom what she wanted done if she were to go into cardiac arrest and she was adamant that she wanted to be resuscitated. She was completely at the mercy of those who made the decision that her life was of no more value. They did not give a damn what she wanted.
The only thing that these “death panels” are going to do is extend this thinking to groups that as of now are protected from these ghouls. You might be a thirty-something with cancer. “Oh, we’re so sorry! We’ve decided that it’s just too expensive for the collective to provide you with the surgery and drugs that would save you. If we had only caught this earlier when it wouldn’t have been so expensive…..Oh, yes, we did do away with that yearly test didn’t we…”
Report this comment
ellietoo
Jan. 29, 2013 at 8:07amSo the job of this panel is to cut expenses but increase quality. The pay is bad and they are going to be making very unpopular decisions. Sounds like a perfect set up for Obama to have to appoint people of his choosing for these positions. No reputable medical person is going to give up what they are doing for less pay and constant criticism. We will have political appointments ruling our medical care apart from any elected person’s oversight, except of course the present regime.
Report this comment
CunningLawyer
Jan. 29, 2013 at 7:36amNo worries, with the Obama worshiping media, it will soon be “cool” to serve on the panel. Being “cool” is all that matters to the useful idiot worshipping public segment that votes for cool and the media who supports same. One day they will be on the receiving end of all this madness. Everyone ages. But then it will be too late.
Report this comment
I Aint PC
Jan. 29, 2013 at 6:58amI’ll volunteer to be on the “Death Panel.” My first choice would be that the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) should be put to death. The “death panel” would then be dissolved.
Report this comment
burke
Jan. 29, 2013 at 6:07amThe only one that should be on a death panel is Obama.
Report this comment
ALL-IN
Jan. 29, 2013 at 5:34amBloomberg will do it!
Report this comment
bumpkin
Jan. 29, 2013 at 5:10amI’ll serve on it! Pick ME! As an RN, I’d LOVE to serve on it! Want something done RIGHT, do it yourself! That panel might not WANT me, however! :( Bet I wouldn’t get to stay long.
Report this comment
NOBALONEY
Jan. 29, 2013 at 4:50amReally doesn’t matter, and the president knows it. The default in the ‘Independent Payment Advisory Board’ (death panel) gives the sole power to make decsions to the HHS Secretary (Sebelius).
Report this comment
sasquatch08
Jan. 29, 2013 at 2:52am‘“The Independent Payment Advisory Board brings unpredictably and uncertainty to providers,” said Rep. Allyson Y. Schwartz (D-Pa.). She favors doing away with the board altogether.’
Why not just do away with Obamacare? This whole thing is a mess already and it’s only going to get worse.
“Yes, if the administration finds it cannot staff the panel, its duties and power will be temporarily transferred to the Secretary of Health and Human Services.”
Temporarily my ****.
Report this comment
CunningLawyer
Jan. 29, 2013 at 7:37amOr to Obama “Himself”.
Report this comment
berlet98
Jan. 29, 2013 at 1:55amLord of the Presidential Flies
The following are not doctored, photo-shopped pictures of America’s President Barack Hussein Obama beset by common houseflies but actual photos of flying insects that seem oddly attracted to Obama.
Now, of course, flies are virtually everywhere, breeding whenever and wherever they’re inclined to do the deed, spreading diseases, feasting on dogsh*t, garbage, and political droppings in cities like Washington D.C. and reveling on dung, sweat, and silage in more pristine rural areas.
What’s inescapable are the spooky parallels between William Golding’s deeply symbolic, post-World War II novel Lord of the Flies and President Obama, parallels relating more to the insects than to their lord. . . (Read more and see the pictures of Obama and his flies at http://www.genelalor.com/blog1/?p=29808.)
Report this comment
nesmond
Jan. 29, 2013 at 1:18amAbortion. Gun confiscation. Death panels. Did I wake up in China? Someone’s gotta stop this madness.
Report this comment
savagenatn
Jan. 29, 2013 at 12:21amdo you mean the death panel that these jackasses all said will never happen?
Report this comment
Zeke48
Jan. 29, 2013 at 12:01amThen why don’t I see my post
Report this comment
Zeke48
Jan. 28, 2013 at 11:49pmHey WINEDUDE
You sound just like one of those Black Panther ******* mouthing off
Report this comment
dadsrootbeer
Jan. 28, 2013 at 11:47pmLooks like Obammy needs to put together another department to work on it. 200,000 new government employees in 4 years and counting.
Report this comment
spirited
Jan. 28, 2013 at 11:23pmMembers will serve six-year terms and during that time they are prohibited from participating in “any other business, vocation or employment.”
>Talk about a life sentence
Report this comment
Chromo200
Jan. 28, 2013 at 10:53pmI wonder if you are on teh panel for life .. If so We conservatives send our names in, load the board and do exactly what panel should not do. If the libs can lie, so can I on this subject.
I wonder if That Guy’s uncle and aunt will be brought up to the panel to choose to get health benefits. We know he won’t give them money, but will get the Saudi’s to so. His Family in Kenya are doing great.
Report this comment
Backfire
Jan. 28, 2013 at 10:42pm“Anyone on the death panel will be called Dr. Death. They might need as much protection as the president.”
Your right, I bet somebody(s) waiting for such folk to step forward and join the Death Squad only to find a boat tail ruining his shirt.
Report this comment
Verceofreason
Jan. 28, 2013 at 10:40pmThat’s because there’s no such thing as a death panel
Or a commentator on FOX named Sarah Palin.
Report this comment
topperj
Jan. 28, 2013 at 10:10pmHe can just find 15 actors to weawr white coats, like he did in the Rose Garden. Problem solved.
Report this comment
Netsurfer2
Jan. 28, 2013 at 10:00pmThe sad thing is that I always really wonder if anyone in our government really even cares about the common working person! Who really represents me? I honestly feel so lost because now they want more and more without ever contributing themselves! Now days even the common person cannot live anymore without the government taking more! Why do you need to work hard when the poor get it for free and the rich find more loop holes not to pay their share (hence Hollywood and such)! You just see the middle class becoming more and more poorer!
Report this comment
NigelTufnel
Jan. 28, 2013 at 9:50pmKathy Sebilus’ father Jack Gilligan was defeated in the 73′Ohio Gubenatorial election by former Governor James A. Rhoads who was directly responsible for the Kent State fiasco. And just to show how much distain Ohioans had for ole Jack….they elected Rhoads again in 77′. Jack hid out teaching at Notre Dame for the rest of his career. The bitterness and revenge in Kathy’s heart must be unmeasurable. I’m sure she’ll start with Ohio republicans.
Report this comment
700P
Jan. 28, 2013 at 9:38pmI vote for Zombie Kevorkian!
Seriously, if I could afford to retire I’d move to a Right to Die state like Oregon and spend my time visiting Death Row inmates to find those who’d like to sue the state for not being allowed to die with dignity and instead suffer through an unfulfilling life in prison.
Report this comment
NigelTufnel
Jan. 28, 2013 at 9:57pmI didn’t know there was any dignity for a murderer.
Report this comment