‘Will You Please Answer the Question’: McCain’s Fiery Exchange With Chuck Hagel Over the Iraq Troop Surge

Getty Images
Sen. John McCain tangled with Chuck Hagel over the Iraq War surge during Hagel’s Senate confirmation hearing Thursday to be the next secretary of defense.
McCain (R-Ariz.) grilled his former colleague over his past stated opposition to the 2007 U.S. troop increase, particularly how he once calling it the “most dangerous foreign policy blunder in this country since Vietnam.” Despite repeatedly being asked for a yes-or-no answer, the former Republican senator for Nebraska didn’t budge.
“Do you stand by those comments, Senator Hagel?” McCain asked.
“Well senator, I stand by them because I made them and — ” Hagel said.
“Stand by,” McCain interjected. “Were you right? Were you correct in your assessment?”
Hagel said he would “defer to the judgement of history” on that, but McCain didn’t let up.
“The committee deserves your judgement as to whether you were right or wrong about the surge,” he demanded. “I want to know if you were right or wrong. That’s a direct question, I expect a direct answer.”
When Hagel said the surge “assisted in the objective,” McCain charged again.
“Will you please answer the question: Were you correct or incorrect when you said that the surge would be the most dangerous foreign policy blunder in the country since Vietnam? Were you correct or incorrect yes or no?…I would like you to answer whether were you right or wrong, and then you are free to elaborate,” McCain said.
“I’m not going to give you a yes or no answer,” Hagel said.
“Well let the record show you refused to answer that question,” McCain said. “Now please go ahead.”
“Well if you would like me to explain why,” Hagel said.
“Actually I would like an answer, yes or no,” McCain fired back.
Hagel said again he wouldn’t do that, repeating that he would “defer that judgement to history.” He said instead that the comment was not strictly related to the surge but that it was more general about the war in Iraq.
“Our war in Iraq I think was the most fundamentally bad, dangerous decision since Vietnam,” Hagel said. “Aside from the cost that occured in this country in blood and treasure, aside from what that did to take our focus off of Afghanistan, which was the original and real focus of a national threat to this county — Iraq was not — I always tried to frame all the different issues before I made a decision on anything.”
Hagel added, “Now just as you said, senator, we can have differences of opinion but that’s essentially why I took the position.”
“It’s a fundamental difference of opinion, Senator Hagel.” McCain replied. “I think history has already made a judgment about the surge, sir, and you’re on the wrong side of it. And your refusal to answer whether you were right or wrong about it, is going to have an impact on my judgement on whether to vote for your confirmation or not.”
In CONTROL, Glenn Beck presents a passionate, fact-based case for guns that reveals why gun control isn’t really about controlling guns at all; it’s about controlling us. Find out more HERE.

















































































































Comments (100)
Carlinpa
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:08pmIt takes a mature adult to take responsibility for failure / actions. Liberals are NOT capable of taking responsibility. They are Unprincipled, therefore they can NEVER be help to any standard or to any responsibility.
Report this comment
jakartaman
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:26pmNominating this guy will signal that America is not serious about our national security or our allies.
I hope clear thinking senators recognize the potential disaster.
Obama nominating Hagel is one more step in bringing America down and into the one world group of countries led by the UN.
I would feel extremely bad for our brave young men and women that would have to call this guy their boss.
Report this comment
Spqr1
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 4:38pmHagel a liberal? What planet are you on? And I haven’t heard any of the former PNAC neocons take responsibility for THEIR failures in either Iraq or Afghanistan.
Report this comment
demsrtraitors
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 5:31pmYou nailed it!
Report this comment
the-most-interesting-troll-in-the-world
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 8:46pmI do not always turn on my friends, but when I do; I prefer to reverse my long standing support for a valued friend – to achieve a “yes or no” slam dunk answer after asking; “when did you stop beating your wife” and, “what did you say about supporting Al Jazeera in 2009?”
Stay unreliably partisan, my friends.
Report this comment
nzkiwi
Posted on February 1, 2013 at 4:27am@ The Most
I understand what you are trying to say in your comment but I think that you are missing the point.
People can be wrong. Nobody is perfect. Senator McCain was asking Senator Hagel whether, with the benefit of hindsight, he considered his earlier position to be right or wrong.
It is not a crime to be wrong, but it goes greatly to Senator Hagel’s character that he will not judge himself. If a leader makes an error of judgement and recognises it to be so, then he will benefit his nation reacts if he reacts immediately and admits it freely.
Senator Hagel could have said that he was not wrong and given reasons. That would also have been acceptable if the reasons were cogent, whether not one agreed with him.
His simple refusal to answer shone a light on a serious character flaw in a man seeking a key position in your government.
Report this comment
the-most-interesting-troll-in-the-world
Posted on February 1, 2013 at 5:28amI don’t always consider the “just answer Yes or No” ploy to bring out the essential True Character of a complex public figure being grilled by Senate hatchet men, but when I do; I prefer to judge Wayne LaPierre for evasively rambling on when asked “yes or no, have you changed your position on background checks” by Senator Patrick Lehey.
Stay duplicitous, my non-American friends.
Report this comment
Verceofreason
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:37pmPoor McCain is high on his irrelevance.
Thought he’d be Sec of State under Romney.
What a pathetic old fart machine and national joke.
Report this comment
The_Jerk
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:02pmWe all know McCain is a caving, progressive wimp, which is why he looks foolish trying to be tough.
Report this comment
barber2
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:14pmBarak Obama and his fellow radicals thank you both.
Report this comment
techengineer11
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 5:04pmSick!
McCain trying to make is sound as if there is any sort of Patriotism for what we did in Iraq?? OMG it was an unmitigated disaster! A trillion dollars thousands dead, 10s k injuries and it is if we never went??
OMG Go to hell McCain, Lieberman, Bush, Lindsey Graham.. Please go straight to hell! Not even Neo-Cons buy the **** any longer!
Just disgusting.. Have to hang my head in utter shame every time I hear the word Iraq!
Simply a Jewish War of choice.
Report this comment
LakeHartwellSailor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:33pmGiven the hearings last week with H. Clinton….these Senators were much tougher on Hagel than Hillary…..where the heck were the tough questions LAST WEEK? Not that they were particularly tough on Hagel…more “semi-tough”.
Last week, I thought I was watching a pee-wee T-ball match….where everyone plays nice, no one strikes out, and everyone wins…..YIPPIE!
Report this comment
krackerhac
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:30pmWas Iraq right or wrong? If I was preparing to go to war again radical muslims, I would have to realize that my targets would be in many countries located in the Middle East. Now, I have no true allies there except Israel. Where would I put my Army. Would I attack a nation I had never before fought or would I attack a nation I had previously defeated. Which would be weaker? Which one could I more easily defeat and would cause less death to my soldiers. Which enemy would I know better? I believe Iraq was the correct choice. The only problem is we haven’t defeated the true enemy yet. It’s a country called Iran. Are our forces still in place and able to launch an attack?
Report this comment
LakeHartwellSailor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:35pmI don’t care what your stance on the war in Iraq….WMD’s (or not), it was justified. I still remember seeing the message traffic coming in when I was in the middle of the Indian Ocean (Gonzo station) when the Kurds were gassed by Saddam.
He was a mad-man, and needed to die….along with his sons.
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:47pmpre-emptive war based on a lie is never justified. This is why the american people continue to avoid the republican party.
Iraq was not run by radical muslims. Iran has a few radical muslims in charge but the people of iran are far less radical muslim than the rest of the middle east. People of iran have a long, proud history and the people are very moderate in their views.
In the pursuit of destroying all types of evil, we have become evil ourselves
Report this comment
jas7751
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:03pmSOY….What lie?
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:30pmjas7751, are you being serious?
Report this comment
Spqr1
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 4:40pmAnd what “radical muslims” in Iraq are you taling about. Saddam ran a secular brutal dictatorship.
Report this comment
frogg
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:30pmJust like all the other BS the Dems. come up with. they’ll lie their @$$es off every chance they get. They want to take our country and rip it apart. People had better wake up or they wake up to being marched off to death camps! Ask the jews from Germany, IF YOU CAN FIND ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Report this comment
Reptillica
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:17pmIf ONLY Mc-Lame was that tough on Obama’s un-constitutional acts such as the attack on Libya and murder of a head of state ( war crime according to the Geneva convention ),…by passing congress….ramming socialized medicine down our throats or the countless other treasonous acts…. but then again, Mc-Lame co-authored the NDAA for indefinite detention of Americas without due process. They’re ALL crooked.
Report this comment
techengineer11
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 7:52pmBump that!
Report this comment
taintso
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:59pmYes and No are not in a politicians vocabulary when asked questions, that is the fundamental problem. They are noting more than professional liars, with Obama, Gore, and the Clintons at the top of the heap.
Report this comment
Kolbie
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:57pmOverall I was slightly disappointed in Sen McCain’s questioning, in that he should have been ever stronger. I hope “Obama Care” covers surgeries repairing a**holes because Lindsey Graham just tore him a new one! In the opening comments he stated that he fully supports the President’s positions and those of the Joint Chief’s. Under direct questioning he seems to shy away from his past statements, has then admitted to having some existing conflicts with current policies, but says his votes clearly establish his beliefs. He cannot have it both ways.
Report this comment
naughtycal
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:11pmIt’s very simple hagel or anyone who can’t answer direct questions with a definative answer should not be confirmed to any position in our government. The people need to step in and stop the dog and pony show and replace it with an honest and straight forward regulation policy.
Report this comment
Verceofreason
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:38pmDId Linsday hit him with his purse?
Report this comment
hauschild
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:54pmAh, nothing quite like the sight of two RINO’s trying to pretend they’re anything but. Comical, yet sad.
Report this comment
chips1
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:02pmMcCain is one big YES vote!!!!
Report this comment
riseandshine
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:43pmIraq Surge = Turning off the spigots before Bush left office.
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:50pmin my opinion, all the surge did was drive the extreme islamists to places like syria, pakistan, afganistan, lebonon, egypt, libya, etc. Just shuffling the deck chairs on the titanic. We then saw afganistan deteriorate and then arab spring
But the Iraq surge cost money and troop fatigue – so it was probably a net negative
Report this comment
riseandshine
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:13pmI believe the ‘surge’ was just cover for what was really going on.
Report this comment
rochrealtor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:35pmMcCain has the nak to make the enemy look good! He surely help Hagel today!
Report this comment
CatB
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:46pmJust heard that Hagel endorsed Obama over McCain in 08. Two RINO’s who are feuding. Before 08 .. actually 13 years ago McCain said that Hagel might be his pick for this very job!
Report this comment
chips1
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:08pmMcCain also endorsed Obama in 2008. McCain has PTSD.
Report this comment
KidCharlemagne
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:30pmIs it still too late to ask the North Vietnamese to take John McCain back? (LOL):
——————————————
Jan. 28, 2013: “John McCain: Immigration Reform Effort Tribute to Ted Kennedy”
Report this comment
MAULEMALL
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:52pmMcCain is a hero. You are a sniveling POS fly on a Pile of S***
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:10pmeverything good that McCain did in asia and for his fellow vets….Has been overshadowed by his progressive republican ideology. Remember McCain-Feingold? That alone was worse than all the good stuff he did in his previous years
Report this comment
Verceofreason
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:38pmThey should have cover that lousy pilot in dirt.
Report this comment
LakeHartwellSailor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:45pmNot even remotely funny. I don’t agree with McCains whimpish political leanings….but he endured five long painful years in the NVA POW system. Despite his father being an Admiral, he refused early release so as to deny the North Vietnamese a propaganda victory. He wouldn’t go until everyone could go.
I strongly suggest you do a little reading about POW’s, particular from the Vietnam era. It will certainly open your eyes as to what these men endured. James Stockdale, himself a POW wrote a powerful book regarding his years in the POW system, you will find references to McCain and his conduct. You also might want to read about Everett Alverez….I believe he was one of the first, if not the first POW.
There is also one man, an enlisted man, not an officer, and I cannot remember his name; who was ORDERED to take an early release by his superior officers in the prison system because he had memorized the names of all the POW’s. This was a way to get word back to the United States of who had been captured. Fascinating stories.
No sir, your little “joke” is not funny AT ALL!
Report this comment
KidCharlemagne
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:54pmLakeHartwellSailor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:45pm
Not even remotely funny. I don’t agree with McCains whimpish political leanings….
============================
Sure you do…….that’s why you jumped in to defend all the Ted Kennedy worshippers out there….
Report this comment
LakeHartwellSailor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:01pm@KidCharlemagne
Really? Is that the best you can do?
Report this comment
barber2
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:44pmHey, kiddies, You do a stint as a POW and then you can criticize McCain all you want.
Report this comment
LakeHartwellSailor
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 4:00pm@barber2
Precisely. I don’t know how KidCharlemagne made the transition to the Teddy Kennedy “worshipping” when my point was his “joke” about wondering if the North Vietnamese would “take McCain back” was highly inappropriate. Politics aside, a veiled reference to wishing an American, any American to be imprisoned as a POW is despicable. I guess Kiddie, figures POW camps are all like those old Hogan’s Heroes episodes.
Made my blood boil; but then again, I’ve read many books on the subject of Prisoner of Wars, and I do tend to focus on the Vietnam conflict in general. The NVA were brutal to the POW’s.
Report this comment
AmericaMustBeFree
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:25pmWhen they are wrong or are lying.. they can never give a simple yes or no answer! This administration is fraught with people who are always wrong and lie always!
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:38pmthe only question McCain had asked was “do you stand by those comments?” Hagel’s immediate answer was “Yes”.
When Mcain interupted Hagel for a followup question, Hagel’s answer was that he would defer to history….Which is the correct response
Report this comment
The_Veteran
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:52pmI have to agree with Soybomb, Hagel answered the question. When McCain pressed him for a yes or no answere, Hagel gave the correct response because it would only be a matter of opinion as to whether Hagel was right or wrong. McCain was just being an ass. I had my doubts about Hagel, but when he starts talking about saving blood and treasure wasted in Iraq, I have to agree. Now get them the hell out of Afghanistan.
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:23pmEVERYONE NEEDS TO WATCH THE VIDEO
McCain is a freaking idiot. The ONLY reason John McCain cares about this issue is because he staked an entire presidential campaign around the Iraq surge. That is in fact how he got nominated by the republicans in 2007 cuz before the surge started temporarily going well – his campaign was going nowhere. John McCain is fighting for his legacy on this issue – nothing more. Good God, the republican party will never get passed the sins of Iraq War
John McCain asked one question “Do you stand by those remarks”. The first thing Hagel said was “Yes”. Then McCain interrupted with follow-up questions and would not let Hagel say anything otherwise. Watch the video. What a joke
Report this comment
Verceofreason
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:40pmThis is another 15 minutes for McCain.
As they say in Tinsel Town even BAD publicity is better than no publicity.
Little Johnny will do and say ANYTHING for a slot on Meet the Press.
Report this comment
paulsfam4
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:20pmcommunist
Report this comment
civilwarcometh
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:35pmAnd he like’s Muslims…http://weaselzippers.us/2013/01/31/video-hagel-at-confirmation-hearing-defends-irans-government-as-elected-legitimate/
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:40pm@civilwar
Then what do you call all the republicans who say our election wasnt rigged???
you are using a double-standard
Report this comment
civilwarcometh
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:46pm@SOTBOMB: Nope we all no the election’s have been rigged for awhile. Whether it be at the voting booth or the primary’s… We choose nothing…
Report this comment
progressiveslayer
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:19pmSenator McCain will you answer the question why do you insist on plaguing us with your presence? Why don’t you retire immediately so someone who understands the constitution can take your place.
Report this comment
BODYBAG
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:43pmHow about someone who understands the ECONOMY ?
Dem leader Reid: ‘We are in a recovery’
http://thehill.com/blogs/floor-action/senate/280307-reid-we-are-in-a-recovery
““Growth went down in the fourth quarter because of reduced government spending,” Reid said. “The economy was rejecting the austerity and brinkmanship.”
These people are INSANE. Growth went negative because of reduced Gov spending?
The current pump from the FED is $85 BILLION A MONTH.
I get a mental picture of these loons in private with Bernanke singing
“Me So Hauney, Me So Hauney”
Report this comment
progressiveslayer
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:00pmLol Yes they’re definitely rearranging the chairs on the deck aren’t they? They’re spending us into oblivion,Ben is digitizing like there’s no tomorrow and Germany and others want their gold back. Everything’s going to be A OK,just ask any brain dead Obamazombie and they’ll tell ya.
Report this comment
CWPrequired
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:08pmA dog and pony show!!! Any takers on a $10 bet he gets approved?
Report this comment
floridaborn
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:20pmNope. I’m still in shock that the America-hating, Jane Fonda loving, Swift boat lying, horse-faced John Kerry is our new Secretary of State without even a whimper from the Senate Republicans. Get ready, the world is reaching a tipping point, and I don’t think we are on the winning end!
Report this comment
Shasta
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:25pmNo bets. Of course he gets approved. This is just a chance for the libs and rinos to flap their jaws and pretend they are doing America’s business.
Al J Zira
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:07pmOooooo! John McCain got angry! And someone should be worried?
Report this comment
civilwarcometh
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:16pmWoot!http://weaselzippers.us/2013/01/31/thursday-afternoon-war-porn-39/
Report this comment
Cavallo
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:17pmHis doctors should be worried. That blood pressure can’t be good on him. Obama should take some concern for the RINOs health and appoint a democrat, because McLame only gets mad at Republicans.
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:30pmNotice how John McCain didnt even flinch against socialist John Kerry because socialist John Kerry will continue the status quo of unconstitutional wars, drone strikes, and spying on US citizens
But if someone like Hagel comes along, and challenges the idea that all war is good. Then McCain gets pissed
Report this comment
pragmaticpatriot
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:52pmPRETENDED to get angry, smokescreen to cover him touching tongues with kerry and clinton, I agree he is a progressive 1WO drone.
Report this comment
barber2
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 3:46pmSOY: I do find that ” friendship ” between McCain and Kerry a weird one. A POW and an anti-war radical seem an odd couple.
Report this comment
Bonnieblue2A
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:06pmJust another criminal about to take an office appointment. Nothing to look at here folks, the sequestration of our military is at hand. Hagel will be Obama’s handmaiden in its dismantling.
Report this comment
Displacedsoutherner
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:06pm“At this point, Senator McCain, what difference does it make?”
Report this comment
SpankDaMonkey
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:00pm.
McCain is a Traitor I would not answer his questions either. Not that Chuck is any better……
When John gets his Panties in a Wad, how does he pick it out?………
Report this comment
M13
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:19pmHe has his own personal Encinom for that.
Report this comment
chips1
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:28pmM13:
Didn’t see that one coming. Sneaky!
Report this comment
ZAP
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:54pmThere is no honor among thieves….
Report this comment
Dismayed Veteran
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:54pmRemember that in the Naval Service there is a much larger cultural gap between officers and enlisted than there is in the Army. McCain is just acting on his cultural heritage. BTW, I live in Nebraksa and would not vote Hagel in to a position of dog catcher.
Report this comment
huey6367
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:51pmSo, from the answers I am reading, I would assume that he meant he is not going to answer that questiong. Most likely because he is wrong. History has already shown you to be wrong Hagel.
Report this comment
CatB
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:40pmYes .. Johnny will put on a show .. and then vote for him … seen it over and over again. RINO.
Report this comment
SquidVetOhio
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:44pmYep.
See John, this is why water-boarding is a good thing. I bet he would have answered you then.
Report this comment
Steelhead
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:46pmman – John threw a real hissy fit, again.
Report this comment
Cavallo
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:50pmPretty much. Our foreign enemies don’t have much to worry about with this guy, or this administration. Our allies on the other hand…
Report this comment
Steelhead
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 12:50pmI was waiting for John to yell, ‘get off my lawn’-lol
Report this comment
BODYBAG
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:04pmYep, kabuki theatre.
This town needs a new kind of criminal.
Report this comment
WillG
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:16pmAgreed BodyBag. Also an enema.
Report this comment
soybomb315_II
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 1:28pmi bet john mccain will vote against hagel. The only thing that can rouse up the weak principles of mccain is the prospect of someone who doesnt love the idea of war
Report this comment
chips1
Posted on January 31, 2013 at 2:36pmWILLG:
The only difference between waterboarding and an enema, is where to put to water.
Report this comment