
(Photo: NBC4 Washington)
Details are scarce in the case of a Virginia homeowner who shot a suspected home intruder who police say was a teenager from the local high school.
No names have been released at this point, but local and national news outlets are beginning to piece together the story.
ABC7 summarized what’s known at this point:
Loudoun County Sheriff’s officials will only say that between 2:30 and 3 a.m. Sunday, a homeowner in the 4500 block of Pullman Court shot and killed a juvenile intruder. But they won’t say why the intruder was in the house.
Neighbors say the homeowner is a volunteer firefighter. When ABC7 called the closest fire house, the person who answered said no one was permitted to say anything. Neighbors also say the young man who was shot and killed lived nearby.
[...]
“I know it’s an intruder but I don’t see why your first instinct is to shoot somebody,” said Parkview High School graduate Tyler Henderson.
Henderson says he played basketball with the victim only a few days ago. He and Parkview student Caroline Zomparelli say they heard that the young man accidentally went into the house after coming home from a party.
“It’s so shocking…it can happen so quickly,” Zomparelli said.
Sterling resident Jeremy Early said the entire scenario sounds tragic, but he stresses that if the homeowner was caught off guard in the middle of the night by an intruder, the homeowner had the right to defend himself. [Emphasis added]
Apparently condolences and expressions of remorse have flooded local social media networks, and grief counselors will be at the school on Monday.
“It’s a horrible situation,” Early added, saying he doesn’t want to “lay blame” on anybody. “It’s sad that it was a neighborhood boy…and your family.”
Here’s more on the story from NBC4 Washington:
This post may be updated.





















































































































Comments (181)
Lois150
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:30am“accidentally went into the wrong house after coming home from a party”….Just how drunk was this underage kid? Does he often have to break into the house when he comes “home?” Maybe we should demolish and outlaw all neighborhoods where the houses resemble each other. (eye roll)
Prayers go out to the stupid boy’s family. It is devastating. However more prayers and sympathy go to the guy who exercised his constitutional right and defended his family. He has to live among idiots who don’t understand that an intruder at 2 am gives someone the instinct (and right) to shoot.
Report this comment
NickyLouse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:38amLoudon is filled with brand new subdivisions and all the houses are nearly identical. It is more than conceivable that the kid went in the wrong house. He may have been working a late night job to help raise money for his college education.
Report this comment
NickyLouse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:48amBut I see that he was partying. So, my bad for trying to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Report this comment
garbagecanlogic
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:48amLouse: How in the hell do you “go into the wrong house” at around 2:00 in the morning? You just about have to have a key don’t you? You are ASSuming a lot of things.
Praise Be To Obama. Psalm 109:8
The U.N. Out Of The U.S.
The U.S. Out Of The U.N.
Report this comment
THX-1138
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:22pmWas the door locked? If not then the homeowner must share the blame. Leaving the door unlocked and then shooting without a clear and positive threat would be, in my opinion, negligent.
Not saying that that is what happend. Just saying I lock my doors every time I pass through them. Hell, I lock my car door while I fill the tank. Just a habit but I was told early on that it was a sin to leave a door unlocked in that it tempted the weak. A real criminal will go through a locked door; a drunk kid probably will not…
HOOT_OWL
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:46pmWas the door ajar ..? Where there signs of forced entry..?
You know ,police have a 21foot rule . THEN ADD THE NIGHT SEASON. Don’t ask them to take a chance, when it comes to THEIR LIFE.
That’s why states have castle laws.
It protect the owner .They don’t have to prove the intruder was going to do harm ,they just have to BELIEVE the intruder is going to do harm.. This is very unfortunate ,but better the intruder than the home owner.
Let me just add my own personal experience that I had.
My brother has one of these clone houses ,that are identical ,one right after another. He has lived in this house for over ten years and he ALWAYS leaves his side door open. One day I stopped by around noon and I normally just walk on in and yell anyone home.
That day “ Thank God” the door was locked and when I twisted the knob , it wouldn’t open .
Being somewhat puzzled by the situation, I knocked on the door very loud.
The door soon opened and it was a woman in a robe with a laundry under her arm
,who answered the side door ,in her night gown and was quite startled by my presence .
Needles to say I quickly apologized ,gave her a short explanation, when I realized
what I had done and quickly walked “ONE” house over.
YES a person can mistake one house for another…It can happen.
I always say … IF you can….Get a dog.. You cant call off a bullet..
Report this comment
txbren
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:51pmMost people lock their doors at night. So question is… How did he get in. Did he break in ? If he broke in then he more than likely knew it was’nt his home
Report this comment
txbren
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:54pmSo how did the kid get in? Did he just open the door and walk in? Did he break in ? Not very many people have a need to break into their own home.
Report this comment
rangerskippy
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:04pmThis we know.
If the dead kid has a previous record of being caught with burglary tools, having marijuana, having THC in his system, if he has pictures on FB with tattoos, gold teeth and flying the birds, if he was wearing in a hoodie, then he will be declared a national hero worthy of emulation by congress man, and the president will wish to have a son just like him.
Report this comment
Mil-Dot
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:08pmYep, I don’t give a rat’s ass about WHY he went into the house. None of that is an excuse. If you wander, stagger, crawl, walk on your hands or sleepwalk into somebody’s dwelling, and you get blasted, well then that is just tough crap. So what did they expect the homeowner to do? Ask him what he was doing there and risk getting his family killed. He did the right thing.
Report this comment
obrien871
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:14pmyou bust the door open to my house and you’re about a second away from being blasted… that being said when lived in florida my neighbor told me a story about how he almost checked out… he was a former pro-basketball player 6’10″ and big as a house… he said he had got in an argument with his live-with girlfriend and got mad and took off and got loaded at a bar… when he came home he accidentally went to a home a street over that looked just like his… when his key didn’t work he started banging on the door… and finally he said he got enraged thinking his girlfriend had changed the lock so the literally kicked the door off the hinges and stormed into the front hallway… where he met the homeowner pointing a 12 gauge shotgun at him… at which point he realized it wasn’t his house and he yelled sorry and ran out… but he himself admits if the guy had shot him it would’ve been his fault and just bad luck.
Report this comment
redfish52
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:16pmThis happened to a young man that worked with me. He went out to a local bar and got trashed and walked home. He opened the door and took off his clothes and slept on the couch….problem was it wasn’t his home…luckily the guy that owned the home was kind enough to wake him up and not call the police. He told the boy he had been dumb and stupid at one time in his life too. But he also told him that he did have a gun in the house and had he been woken up he would have used it…thank God the guy was a heavy sleeper. I’m not making any excuses for the kid that was shot and even take offense that one of his friends called him the victim…just saying kids do dumb s*** and its just the luck of the draw to the outcome.
Report this comment
encinom
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:20pmGuns really make us safe, another kid to add to the NRA’s growing body count.
Report this comment
Steve LeMaster
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:32pmAgreed
Report this comment
chips1
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:37pmENC:
Sounds like you want a law passed that allows anyone that leaves their door unlocked to be open to the public. With all of the citizens that are protecting their families and property, it won’t be long before Americans become the majority again. No more Treyvon stalking for your type.
Report this comment
rangerskippy
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:41pmENCINOM
Your comment – “Guns really make us safe, another kid to add to the NRA’s growing body count”
Do you realize the absurdity of your comment?
When you look nationally, you will find that NRA members that shoot are doing so in their own houses, under the protection of the law, and they are shooting, or stopping criminals?
Do you realize that when you look at murder stats, those doing the shootings are not NRA members? They do happen to be intrinsically tied to welfare, rap music, and failed democrat programs? When is the last time we saw a NRA member rob a 7-11 store? When is the last time we saw an NRA member do a drive by shooting in Detroit, or Chicago? It is Obama voters that are doing the killings.
In major cities like Chicago, 70 % of the murders are tied to gangs and drugs. Gang members from the bloods, crips, MS13, Vice lords… are not NRA members.
These thugs are not using battle carbines. Rifles are used in less than 4% of murders nationally. They are using cheap or stolen handguns.
The majority of those doing murders are staunch supporters of Obama. Check the stats. They are not members of the NRA.
In the early days of the NRA (post civil war), they believe in arming and training black Americans, so white democrats could not stop them from voting, or violate their civil rights.
Keep it real Jack Ass
Report this comment
Maji
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:01pmEincnom,
As always close but wrong (mostly wrong )
A kid intruder.
Another reason not to live in a subdivision.
Report this comment
chingachgook
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:03pmsome mistakes have consequences. No one except for the people involved knows what transpired. I have often said that the house owner is at more risk as he has to ascertain what the actual threat is. The bad gun does not worry about who he is going to rob or harm. the home owner does care and is in a stressful dangerous situation with limited time to evaluate the situation and act accordingly. I would say this kid made a fatal mistake if that is what it was. You know like ignoring a do not walk sign and jay walking across a dark street dressed in all black.
Report this comment
Wino911
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:24pmDitto!
Report this comment
Trigus
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:42pm“The resident reported the house alarm was activated,” Mills said, “and he went to investigate and found an unknown male in the stairwell.” – Going up the Stairwell where his children where.
I have a .45 on the night stand – if the alarm went off during the night – I would have done the same thing.
Only you can make this Once Great Nation, Great Again!!
2013 American Patriot Spring, What will you do?
The distinctions between Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, and Independents are no more. I Am Not A Republican, But An American! – Sons of Liberty
The distinction between Races is no more. I Am Not (Insert Race,) but An American! – Defenders of Liberty
Report this comment
00100111
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:02pm““I know it’s an intruder but I don’t see why your first instinct is to shoot somebody,” said Parkview High School graduate Tyler Henderson.”
Well, Tyler, because he was an intruder. You see, breaking into someone’s home (whether on drunken accident, or not) is still breaking and entering. No homeowner is his right mind is going to ask you 20 questions to determine your mindset at 2:30 in the morning. The kid brought it on himself. He was too drunk to know what was going on, went into the wrong house, got shot. Sorry, but it’s his own fault. He should have known better than to get into that situation in the first place.
Consider it a little chlorine in the gene pool.
Report this comment
00100111
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:08pmEncy, the only reason you don’t like this story is that it reminds you there are consequences to your actions. You want govt to hold your hand at every corner and not have to be accountable. Breaking and entering is illegal and is grounds to get shot, whether you’re drunk and it’s an accident (read, irresponsible) or intentional. The kid is a Darwin Award winner.
Report this comment
Thighmaster
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:18pmHe broke a window and gained entry that way, it’s tragic but shouldn’t the news be about the alcohol that brought him to this end ?
Report this comment
carbonyes
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:26pmEncinom(jacka$$), the NRA don’t have a body count. Make yourself useful and keep your own body count. Makes about as much sense as your post.
Report this comment
retired_leo
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:30pmI have to agree 100% with you.
First we have an underage person drinking ( violation)
Second the deceased appears to be severely intoxicated (not sure if he was violent).
Third the deceased may of entered in to the residence forcibly (a violation of law).
We also do not know if there had been prior crimes of breaking and entering in the area. As you pointed out yes it is tragic but again it shows actions have consequences. The deceased chose to break several laws and paid for his unwise choices.
We need to ban the consumption of alcohol by underage persons and ban the size of the bottles. If these bottles were smaller think of how many people could be saved. Better yet we should make the manufacture, importation, possession or sale of alcohol illegal.
Report this comment
desertspeaks
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:38pmencinom why don’t you post your address so the rest of us can just wander through your house and take what we want. assuming you have anything worth taking that is.. and don’t forget, you can’t shoot us! and the time doesn’t matter, we can wander through at our pleasure without giving any thought to your safety or your rights!
that seems to be your take on things of late!
Report this comment
JRook
Mar. 18, 2013 at 5:24pm@Lois150 No where does it say the boy broke into the house. Perhaps one or more doors was unlocked. In any case there is something to be said about making your best determination before shooting to kill. Defending your family is not a license to shoot and shoot to kill in every situation that might come up. That is the fundamental problem with the nonsensical Stand your Ground laws. It is not a matter of you feeling threatened, it is a matter of being threatened. A 6 foot 8, 300 lbs individuals may well look and be threatening in a confrontation, but that in and of itself does not justify deadly force, if the individual has not overtly threatened you, particularly if he does not have a weapon of any kind. Let’s keep in mind this was a kid and he does in no way deserve to be shot because he was at a party and made a mistake, even if that mistake was due to having too much to drink.
Report this comment
uziah51
Mar. 18, 2013 at 7:42pmnothing good happens after 2 a m a jr shouldnt be out at a party until 2 a m i might think the parents
deserve alot of the responsibility no matter the boys intent a call to the police happened after he entered and before he was shot the intent does not sound innocent
Report this comment
SgtB
Mar. 18, 2013 at 8:41pmno one here is asking the truly relevant questions. Like where in the hell were the parents of this minor and why were they letting him break what is probably a city curfew on minors while getting completely hammered drunk at a party? I used to work late, sometimes past midnight while I was in school, but this idiot was getting drunk and attempting to contract a disease and his parents didn’t have anything to say about it.
The parents should be the ones who feel guilt over the death of their son. Not the man who protected his family from an unknown but very real threat in the early hours of the morning.
Report this comment
VAMinuteman
Mar. 18, 2013 at 8:42pmTHX-1138, in MANY parts of this country, and VA specifically, people still leave their doors unlocked because it’s fairly routine. Nonetheless, being locked or not it doesn’t matter. Even if somebody walks through a wide-open doorway without permission, that is still at a minimum unlawful entry, and any illegal entry into your home is considered to represent a threat to you. VA is ruled by case law, and case law dictates the ability to use deadly force without the need to retreat, so long as you feel physically threatened with harm. Unlawful entry into a home creates a presumption of intent to harm, and therefore deadly force is authorized.
Report this comment
Scaredfuzz
Mar. 18, 2013 at 9:46pmSgtB:
Apparently the kid had been grounded by his parents and snuck out to go party. He also broke a window to gain access to the house, set off and alarm and alerted the homeowners dogs, yet was so drunk didn’t even phase him. The home owner was also on the phone with 911.
This neighborhood is a very wealthy one, but it sits on the edge of sterling park, which has a large MS-13 gang influence and ARMED robberies and home invasions are not uncommon especially for the richer neighborhoods. As sad as this was you could very well be reading about two gangbangers getting shot.
Sad thing is the kid only lived two doors down from where he was shot. That’s going to be a rough time for both families.
My brother went to high school with this kid, and my family lives just a couple minutes down the road from where this happened, in case anyone is wondering.
Report this comment
Golum
Mar. 19, 2013 at 12:46amLois150…right on!
Report this comment
Scaredfuzz
Mar. 19, 2013 at 1:38amJrook:
VA doesn’t have a stand your ground law, just common law allowing defense of property. There’s very good case law throughout the history of VA to not warrant a need for a castle doctrine law.
Report this comment
Redfor
Mar. 19, 2013 at 7:28am……… Really? Ok.. Just remember to ask EVERY burgler/rapist/etc if they’re sure they’re in the right house before you defend yourself. Tragic? Yes.. But I would have to side with the home owner on this one.
Report this comment
Protege
Mar. 19, 2013 at 10:46amRangerSkippy:
Don’t bother to try to reason with encinoman. He’s just ticked he drew the short straw on Soros’ “Mandatory Troll Overtime” program and had to work this weekend. He had plans on hitting the bong, chowing down on some Fun-Yuns, and playing WOW until he was forced to actually WORK (or what passes for work among trolls). Just let him be angry, and only respond to him from 9am – 4:30 pm Mondays through Fridays. When Soros figures out the weekend trolls are ineffective, he’ll stop forcing them to work the weekends and all the trolls will be much happier. I mean, really, you’d be doing them and us a favor! We get weekends back with no trolls, and they get to use that Soros money and welfare support to get high, visit strip clubs, and play WOW.
It’s a win-win for both of us! So, have mercy on any trolls you encounter outside of their usual time slot of 9 am-4;20 pm Monday – Friday. The troll you save, may just look like Obama’s son (if he had one).
Report this comment
OpenTheDoor
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:28amI live out in the country but have pretty close neighbors. I leave the door unlocked all the time.
If I were to be awakened by a young strong man at 02:30 in the morning not sure how I would react.
Not going to happen though, I have the always active, always alert, always effective intruder deterrence system.
BFBlackDog makes it so I am up, armed and ready to greet, prior to them opening my door.
Report this comment
HooterBro388
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:16amBack about 20 years ago, I was stationed in Korea. Some friends and I had WALKED to a club about a mile outside the camp. We proceeded to get blackout drunk. It was the first time I’d ever had a blackout and was from drinking Soju. Still, I managed to walk, or stumble, back to my camp, get through the gate, walk to MY barracks and go to MY barracks room and lay down in MY bed. So I find it hard to buy the mistaken house thing unless the kid had JUST moved in. Still, as others have said, why was he out that damned late? Why was he not with a friend? I don’t care what age you are, you come walking into my house at zero dark thirty, you’re gonna catch some JHP lead for your stupidity. Ultimately, this is the parents fault. But how much you wanna bet they’ll be on TV blaming the guy who shot him?
Report this comment
StanW
Mar. 18, 2013 at 6:50pmDamn right they homeowner is getting lamed, Washington Post headline reads: “Loudoun homeowner shoots, kills teen from neighborhood.”
Report this comment
Cavallo
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:15amLine up the pictures of him when he was 12.
Report this comment
Wolf
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:34pmIf oblahblah had a son, he would look like this kid.
Report this comment
thegreatcarnac
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:33pmNo…12 is too old. Let’s see a picture of him on a tricycle.
Report this comment
GOFORT
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:07am@stumpy- if the doors were unlocked it makes it more plausible that he merely entered the wrong house.
Report this comment
Polarized America
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:33amya, something doesn’t sound right…The volunteer firefighter calls 9-11 @ 2:30 am and than he kills the kid.. and it doesn’t say if the Firefighter had any family, or if anyone else lived at the home.
just because he’s a firefighter doesn’t mean he’s a good guy ( sex,,drugs ) who knows, we need more info, and it seems that people just wanna cheer about a dead guy ……..
personally, i hope it was a justified shooting and not a murder or manslaughter
Report this comment
garbagecanlogic
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:50amGofort: If, if, if, if, if, if.
Praise Be To Obama. Psalm 109:8
The U.N. Out Of The U.S.
The U.S. Out Of The U.N.
Report this comment
Mil-Dot
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:30pmI was trying to figure out , as others have noted , why the media found it important to say the homeowner is a volunteer firefighter. I think I know why. You see, firemen are often lumped together with cops. You know, the ones that are supposed to be heros that look and act like Superman, casting good deeds about with reverence and protecting truth, justice and the American way? If one of THESE incredibly gifted and generous persons could make such a mistake, just think about the average low-life working stiff and how irresponsibly he may act if HE had a gun.
Report this comment
RodT82721
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:07amNothing good ever happens after the bars close. Never!
I wonder why is it important to note that the home owner was also a volunteer fireman? What does that have to do with protecting your home and family from invasion?
Looks to me like this article is written to enhance the gun grabbers campaign to end the right to have guns. Once again the intruder learned too late not to invade someone’s home.
Is it a crime not to lock your door?
Was that why this person was in the home at that early hour, he thought he was home?
This is just another Trayvon event, where the gun grabbers are going to blame the protector.
Report this comment
dnewton
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:34amIt is not unusual for a mentally impaired person to break into the wrong apartment thinking that the key suddenly decided not to work. Social services often finds them apartments to live in next to yours instead of being in an institution. Several years ago, a lady in Nashville came home to find her door broken and the intruder fixing himself a sandwich and loudly complaining that someone “stole his beer.” Fortunately, in this Nashville case, de-institutionalization did not end badly except the intruder was charged with a crime while the real perpetrators, Social Services, skated free.
Report this comment
crusaderx9
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:05amIt’s a simple rule…
Report this comment
sparky239
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:04amthat punk should have known better..one thing Where were the parents and why was this kid out at 230 am…second thing that punk that ran up to his door acting stupid should have been taken down a few pegs as well …makes you wonder about the parents raising ability …
Report this comment
StanW
Mar. 18, 2013 at 6:26pmExactly, it’s 12:00AM do you know where your kids are? Just like the poor 16 year old girl that got raped in Ohio, where the hell were the parents before that happened?
Report this comment
Witness1974
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:04amAn intruder is an intruder. I don’t see how age is relevant here. How can anyone make the claim that he accidentally entered the home?
Report this comment
naughtycal
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:11amExactly, the homeowner only knew one thing. Someone possible armed had broken into his house.
End of story. The time it takes to say freeze or shout anything is the time it takes for the inturder to pull a trigger of his own.
And as far as people saying they know the intruder.
Well people knew darmah,buddy and gacey as well. But look at what monsters they were.
Report this comment
chicago76
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:46amMost break-ins are done by people you know. They know you too. They know what you got and where you keep it. Too bad the kid got killed, but he took his chances when he decided to rob that guy.
Report this comment
termyt
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:17pmViolent home intrusions are the reason for castle doctrine laws. Accidental home intrusion are the reason for laws requiring homeowners to flee first were passed.
I won’t pretend to understand anyone’s motivations – either the homeowner (why do we need to know he is a volunteer fire fighter?) or the intruder. I will give them both benefit of the doubt for the moment.
Absent any malice on the part of either homeowner or intruder, I would expect a different result. While I support the right to defend yourself and your home, simply shooting anyone who is there unexpectedly is not a good policy.
If no malice can be proven on the part of the homeowner, I don’t see how you convict him. But without any malice on the part of the intruder, I don’t see why you shoot him. If you are that nervous a person, perhaps you ought to seek some training before you violently defend what is not at risk.
Look before you shoot. Please.
Report this comment
NinjaJuice
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:09pmYup,.. there is no proof that it was an accident. If accident is to blame then the home owner must have accidently fired a few rounds.
Report this comment
00100111
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:11pmTermyt, are we to now as 20 questions to any intruder before advising him he will be shot? Perhaps we should offer him a coke and a smile after he bashed in our door at 230am?
Report this comment
2GodBeTheGlory
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:14pm@termyt
You obviously do not know the rules of engagement with criminals. Any police, or tactical training would educate you that even announcing yourself to an intruded (criminal) in the dark can get you shot. You are under NO obligation to say “freeze”, “stop”, or ask for an intruders intent. How about asking for their drivers licenses, or the their past 4 addresses, or if their married or not? Any trained individual would know that you have a split second to decide if you forfeit your life, your family’s life, or the intruder.
You want to ask them of their intent, go ahead, however, I do not recommend and action that could get you killed.
Report this comment
DoseofReality
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:40pmWhen i was a kid another neighborhood kid with severe autism somehow made his way into our hosue in the middle of the night…we found him sleeping on our couch in the morning. I guess in your perfect shoot first world you would have gone down guns blazing and killed this kid. Are you people so paranoid that your first instinct is to just open fire? What world do you freakin people live in? You all make me sick. We do not know the story here…but if its a gun issue, everyone heres opinion is just to shoot to kill….bunch of sick, gun obsessed people here.
Report this comment
2GodBeTheGlory
Mar. 18, 2013 at 5:13pm@DoseofReality
As a parent of a classic autistic child, I take offense of you using a child to say that this is a “gun issue”.
When I was a child, many things where different than they are today, and I have more knowledge than my father did at the same age where he still did not pull his gun unless needed. It was unheard of back then for someone to come into the home while people where in the house. Today, it’s a daily occurrence. Because we live in a different time and because we have lots of innocent deaths due to people not knowing how to handle a situation, we know now to NOT announce presence. Not even to chamber the round as even that can get you killed. You should have the round chambered already and release safety only when absolutely necessary.
It does not mean that you MUST SHOOT immediately, any sane, responsible person would attempt to asses the situation before taking such a drastic, life altering action. This is not to say that if it is necessary to shoot immediately that you should delay, just if you have the opportunity to wait, then you wait. As a responsible person, that holds life up in high regard, I do not shoot “just for the kill”, but in order to protect my life and the life of my family. If you don’t agree, that’s your right, I just hope you don’t have to face your decision.
Again, this is not a “gun” conversation as you put it, the problem is with the ACTIONS of a PERSON!
Report this comment
2GodBeTheGlory
Mar. 18, 2013 at 5:17pm@DoseofReality
“shoot to kill”? Really, you want to go there with that childish statement. I guess that you think nobody out there kills indiscriminately because you haven’t seen it?!
Report this comment
biohazard23
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:02amSure, it was a mistake, just one great big misunderstanding.
And I’m a Brazilian supermodel.
Report this comment
Ms Moommist
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:59amDoes anyone remember the story about ticky-tack houses?
Report this comment
OpenTheDoor
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:08amSong, Little Boxes, Malvina Reynolds, Pete Segar made it popular, I like the original best.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SADPuUYF_4I
Report this comment
Ben__Franklin
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:59amHe was a good student, he was only so tired at 3AM that he got confused and thought the Firefighters home was his own. It happens to me all the time. I end up in my neighbors home and they have to remind me I live two houses over.
Report this comment
SpankDaMonkey
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:58am.
“I know it’s an intruder but I don’t see why your first instinct is to shoot somebody,” said Parkview High School graduate Tyler Henderson.
You may need to re-enroll and start over if you can’t figure that one out Tyler…..
Report this comment
Ben__Franklin
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:08amThis is what they are taught. Breaking into someones house is par for the course. The victim is to call the police – not shoot the perp. Johnnie had a long life a head of him breaking into houses.
Report this comment
sparky239
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:19pmblame goes all around,starting with the parents(not in stowing manors and morals )also the idiots he hung with that are a nuisance to the neighborhood ..and also to the punk kid that decided to break in to some ones home..
Report this comment
DoseofReality
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:35pmYes, you dont automatically shoot someone who is in your house – you should only shoot to kill if that person is a direct threat to you. When i was younger a neighborhood kid who was severly autistic got out of his house and enetered ours….we found him in the morning sleeping on our couch. In your utopian shoot first and ask questions later world, my dad should have come downstairs guns blazing and kileld him right? You f’ing people make me sick.
Report this comment
Joe Botz
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:57amDarwin award winner goes to,,the dead moron.
Report this comment
coyote1hell
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:57amWelcome to the Real world….that’s all…
Report this comment
wingedwolf
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:57amSo now we are required to ask for ID and determine a reason before defending ourselves in our own homes in the wee hours? Ask the police if they hesitate and what happens when they do.
Report this comment
Mil-Dot
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:43pmRight on Wolf.
Spook a blue and he will turn you into Swiss cheese in about 3 seconds, then say “who dat?, who der?”
Report this comment
stumpygrim
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:57amUm yeah, he went in the wrong house by accident,my ass! He picked the wrong house to rob,and paid a price for it, no sympathy from me on this one.You want to be a criminal. you better know the consequinces…….
Report this comment
stumpy68
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:38pmThe only warning an intruder gets entering my
house is if my wifes dog wakes up before i do
not likly she is deaf.
Report this comment
IMCHRISTIAN
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:56amWe will have to hear all the facts before judging. Questions will be ask and one will be… why did the boy not call before entering house of another?
Report this comment
smokie
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:13amWait, if the intruder is dead, did his fellow students conduct a Seance to discern that he accidentally went into the wrong house? How are they getting this knowledge of the intruder’s intent after the fact?
I live in a neighborhood of Sear Roebuck houses, all of them different, and have found “thought this was my place” juveniles in my backyard.
The government really needs to safety pin pictures of children’s houses onto their clothes until they are 24 to combat this ‘house confusion’.
Report this comment
IMCHRISTIAN
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:42amlol….They probably need a watch so they know if it is a.m. or p.m and an a tracker so their parents can keep track of them and direct them home.
Report this comment
AlansTigg
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:56am“I know it’s an intruder but I don’t see why your first instinct is to shoot somebody,” said Parkview High School graduate Tyler Henderson.
so what exactly should your first instinct be? Offer them a snack??
Report this comment
Landon410
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:07amhe might have had the munchies……. just saying…
Report this comment
Southerner01
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:21pmThrow up on him, pee on him then stab him with a pen. If that doesn’t work, fire a shotgun out the window a couple times.
Report this comment
Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:55amThis happens to me all the time, accidentally go into my neighbor’s house all the time, and they wander into mine. Such a common occurrence, and of course, at 3 am, I always ask an intruder “Can I help you, are you lost, did you come into the wrong house?” And of course, I usually make them some hot cocoa, before shooting them. Sarcasm Off.
Report this comment
AmericanStrega
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:18am“…hot cocoa, before shooting them.” You CAD! What about the little marshmallows? Have you not considered your offer for hot cocoa without the little marshmallows has now caused an international incident? What the bleep is WRONG with you? How could you forget the little marshmallows!!!! (chuckle)
Report this comment
Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:37amWhy would I waste little marshmellows on someone I am going to shoot? Think man, think.
Report this comment
AmericanStrega
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:55amSorry DARMOK, wasn’t thinking straight. My bad. :)
Report this comment
fdraiden
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:55amI always go into the wrong house after a party. (sarcasm on)
Report this comment
AlansTigg
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:11amactually know a guy who did this, he was drunk and walked into the wrong house and promptly passed out on the couch. Everyone including the guy believes he is very fortunate he was not shot…he did get tazed and spend the night in jail with a broken nose though, so while impaired you CAN enter a house my mistake…however that does not alter the likelihood of being shot
Report this comment
Sara72
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:54am“I know it’s an intruder but I don’t see why your first instinct is to shoot somebody,” said Parkview High School graduate Tyler Henderson
Well TYLER… when you BREAK INTO SOMEONES HOME… Bad things can happen! Tyler a better question would be… what was he doing breaking into someones homes at 2:30 in the morning???? Would you have preferred he invite him in for coffee and scones!
Report this comment
beardedjesse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:02amWe don’t know yet by this story whether or not the person “broke in..” Lets get our facts straight before speaking irresponsibly. We do know the person was in the wrong house obviously and alarmed the homeowner to the point that he used deadly force (which is within his rights). Lets not add embelishments on here that were not indicated as facts in the actual story. Thats completely irresponsible & hypocritical since a lot of the comments on here seek to criticize the Left for doing the same thing. I’m as Conservative as they come but will call a hypocrital situation when I see one.
Report this comment
starman70
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:08amExactly, what if it had been an armed burglar with the intention of killing anyone in the house? How was the homeowner to know?
Had the teen been to a drinking party? Was he drunk or doped up? Why would he break into his own home? Did he not think that his parents might have reacted the same way to a breakin? How long had he lived in the neighborhood? Are the houses so much alike that he mistook this one as his?
This is a very tragic situation for both the family of the boy and for the homeowner. Parents MUST teach their children to ring the doorbell of knock loudly, even it they have been drinking. It is far better to forgive the use of alcohol than to bury your child. PARENTS, TAKE THIS ADVICE – - – YOU MIGHT SAVE YOUR CHILD’S LIFE!!!!
Report this comment
beardedjesse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:17amI know its common sense to ID/attempt to ID an unknown assailant inside your home before taking a shot. If you take a shot inside your home, you’re solely responsible for that bullet, where it goes, who it hits, etc etc. Even taking a life after positively IDing an intruder would work on your nerves I don’t care how “hard” you think you are. I just know when something like this happens…all the armchair quarterbacks come out to say what the person “should have done.” Just a little ironic I think. I just wanted to remind people in a friendly way that whether deadly force is warranted or not it is ALWAYS tragic when someone’s life is taken. By some of the “ivory tower” reactions on here you wouldn’t think that many agree with that last point. Lets be respectful of others & not hypocritical as Conservatives because quite frankly, if you are not, then you’re feeding the Left exactly what they want to eat.
Report this comment
galaxie_man
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:27amInside my home at 2:30 AM you have two choices, (1) backwards out the door and run away, or (2) die. And you had better walk carefully and not stumble towards me while trying to back up. Any move in my direction, accidental or not will end with multiple .45ACP 230 gr. rounds at 900+ fps down range.
My nearest neighbor’s house is a few hundred yards in any direction. Believe me, if you are in my home it is on purpose.
Report this comment
beardedjesse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:50am@Galaxie, so would you make an attempt to ID the person first to make sure it was not a family member or friend messing around? I would just for good coscience…if it was not anyone I knew and they were threatening to come closer despite warnings I’d let them fly at that point. That is my personal line of thinking in a situation like that…I can’t dictate what you do in that case. I just know with all the media coverage of events like this, I would want to be able to go into that court (if the need arises) & say, “look judge, despite multiple warnings, ID attempts, etc etc…the man/woman kept coming toward me, I thought I was in danger as well as my family so as much as I hate it for the other person and their family, I did what I felt I had to do…I did what it was my right to do.” See what I’m saying? Does the actual LAW say that even half of that is required of the individual? No. Would I be able to sleep better at night knowing that I did everything in my power to not let things come to using deadly force like that as a responsible gun owner that doesn’t want something like this one their conscience? Probably. Its very easy for people to come on this website & talk about, “oh yeah, I’d smoke that fool…blah blah blah” (insert big man talk) Sorry but, being RESPONSIBLE with a firearm & a GENTLEMAN with it at the same time isn’t being taught these days at the rate it should be. It is possible to be both of those at the same time.
Report this comment
galaxie_man
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:51pm@BEARDEDJESSE Along with my personal defense implement, I have a SureFire Defender tactical flashlight. My target is positively ID’d first, and always. But I gotta tell you, whoever was in my home in the middle of the night will be answering to law enforcement at the very least. We had an incident at my house at 1:00 AM Christmas morning. My wife was terrified and I was prepared to do whatever was necessary to protect my castle. Luckily the potential intruder/invader caught one glimpse of what I was holding and he left. I will never give the benefit of doubt, or rely on the good graces of a criminal to let me live.
Report this comment
beardedjesse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 2:00pm@galaxie…oh no doubt man, I’m glad everything turned out good for you & your family.
Report this comment
00100111
Mar. 18, 2013 at 3:17pmBearded, I don’t know what kind of friends you have that would be playing a prank at 2:30am by breaking in, but maybe you should get new friends? A family member? No, the only family member in my home is my wife, she’s in my bed, so no it wouldn’t be her. Anyone breaking in at that hour will get what is coming to them. They have the time between hearing the alarm go off and hearing me rack a round into the chamber to GTFO or die.
Report this comment
beardedjesse
Mar. 19, 2013 at 11:12am@001, good for you big man. Could you entertain the idea that some people have more than their wife in their house? Its a stretch but some people have kids, pets, live-in relatives et cetera (and the list could go on). Common sense dictates that in that kind of dynamic home defense environment one should probably try & identify their target or make an attempt before firing. Its a matter of common sense actually. What do I know, I’ve just been clearing corners in buildings, running night operations with IR equipment, lasers & DBAL units for 15 years now? Obviously, since you have just you & the wife in your house my comments wouldn’t apply to you. This is why we think ahead & plan the best we can for active shooter environments, home invasions, hostage situations and other tactical environments. Think about all possible scenarios BEFORE they happen & you’ll react more positively vs. waiting until you’re in the situation scratching your **** going, “hmm, man, I never thought that could happen…” then boom people are dead or seriously injured. GET IT?
Report this comment
Bonnieblue2A
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:53amWere the doors unlocked? If not one cannot just accidentally walk into the wrong house unless the intruder’s parents home and this home were keyed alike.
Kid was allegedly out partying and possibly too chemically impaired to know which home was his? Why is a high school age student out “partying” and where was the parental supervision? Sad all the way around but I do not blame the homeowner.
Report this comment
stumpygrim
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:58am@bonnie.
What differnce does it make if the doors were locked or not?…..
Report this comment
AlansTigg
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:15amhard to explain accidentially entering a house with locked doors…how did you get them open?
Report this comment
Bonnieblue2A
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:24am@ Stumpy, you have to ask? Seriously? Locked door would tell a person who truly made a mistake that they were NOT at their home, especially when the key doesn’t fit. An unlocked door makes it easier for a drunk or other chemically impaired individual to stumble on inside.
Clue: security is about LAYERS. Locking ones’ doors is but one layer. Forcible entry is a crime.
Report this comment
NickyLouse
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:36amBreaking and entering simply means turning a doorknob and going in. The only way a crime was not committed by the intruder is if the door was standing wide open. The homeowner is justified, although I am sure he is not feeling that way today.
Report this comment
chicago76
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:52amA breaking and entering, whether the doors are locked or not, is a B&E. It doesn’t matter as long as he or she has to open a door or window or whatever.
Report this comment
Stoic one
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:49amAnd where were the parents of this intruder during his formative years?
Report this comment
Dushman Kush
Mar. 18, 2013 at 10:47am“Basketball” is the giveaway word in this story.
Report this comment
Landon410
Mar. 18, 2013 at 11:09amif obama had a son….
Report this comment
Kisses6350
Mar. 18, 2013 at 12:53pm@ Landon… Give that a rest, with your un informed ass. Stupid for no reason I swear! Hate to break it to you, but the young man was white that was killed! I guess if “YOU” had a son…………***SMIRKS***
Report this comment
thegreatcarnac
Mar. 18, 2013 at 1:37pmYeah….I thought the same thing. I guess he had to have at least one break-in under his belt before the NBA would even look at drafting him in the future.
Report this comment