Lifestyle

Here’s a look at a new trend called ‘tri-parenting’ and where it’s legal

Courts and lawmakers in at least 12 states have decided that children can have more than two parents as part of a growing trend called “tri-parenting.” (Getty Images)

For some families, a measly two parents just don’t cut it.

When she was 16 years old, Madison Bonner-Bianchi and her three parents, whom she calls “mom,” “dad,” and “mama,” crowded into a California courtroom where Victoria Bianchi joined former partner Kimberli Bonner and friend Mark Shumway to become a parent, The Associated Press reported.

In 2000, Bonner, who was in a partnership with Bianchi, gave birth to Madison. At the time, California allowed for only two legal parents. Shumway, a long-time friend of Bonner and the girl’s biological father, knew it was important for Bianchi to be a legal parent, but at the time he “could not do that, sign away the rights to my daughter,” he said.

But now “tri-parenting” is legal in California, and it’s gaining traction in other states, too.

Bonner-Bianchi, who is now 17, said her parents are just like anyone else’s — “I just happen to have three of them.” The one drawback, she admitted, is it sometimes takes some work to get input from three different parents.

“But the big picture is: You just have more people there to support you and be there for you and love you no matter what,” she said. “Honestly, I look up to all of them.”

In fact, Shumway likes how “tri-parenting” has worked out so much, he wants to do it again: This time with his husband and a female friend.

University of Indianapolis Professor Anita Jones Thomas, who heads the American Psychological Association’s child-and-family section, said three-way parenting can be beneficial to a child.

“That extra sense of social support has really been found to be beneficial for children,” she said.

But not everyone has such a positive perspective about the practice.

One University of Virginia sociologist, W. Bradford Wilcox, said children in two-parent households perform better academically and emotionally.

“This is going to be a family form where children are exposed to more complexity and more instability,” he said of “tri-parenting.”

And that has definitely been the case for Kitty Stillufsen, longtime friend Darren Greenblatt, and his now-husband Sam Hunt. None of them foresaw how difficult “tri-parenting” would be when their daughter — who has Stillufsen and Greenblatt’s DNA and Hunt’s last name — was born in 2009.

The three parents had worked out a plan until 2013, when Stillufsen wanted to marry her California-based boyfriend and enroll her daughter in school in the Golden State. Greenblatt and Hunt objected, so they sued for custody.

When a judge ruled that Hunt is a “psychological parent,” Stillufsen’s California plans were dashed. Now all three parents — who share equal custody of the child — live in New Jersey with their young daughter.

Hunt, however, wasn’t declared a legal parent. The judge said lawmakers needed to decide whether or not “tri-parenting” should be permitted because such a practice will have “far-reaching implications” — a reality Stillufsen is now coming to understand.

She now believes “tri-parenting” is “logically dangerous territory” that creates unnecessary turmoil for children.

“We were naive,” Greenblatt said. “Our example should be a cautionary tale. But then again, we have this beautiful, smart, funny, amazing kid.”

States where “tri-parenting” has had legal success

Despite the difficulties surrounding the three-parent policy, “tri-parenting” is becoming more commonplace.

In addition to California, where Bonner-Bianchi’s parents invoked a 2013 state law that arose after a lesbian couple’s daughter was placed in foster care when her biological father lost a bid to be declared a third parent as he sought custody, and New Jersey, which blocked Stillufsen’s move over the issue, “tri-parenting” has enjoyed legal successes in 10 other states.

California and Maine are the only states, though, that have passed laws protecting “tri-parenting.” The Golden State legalized the practice in 2013 while lawmakers in the Pine Tree State OK’d three-way parenting in 2015.

The state Supreme Courts in Louisiana and North Dakota have ruled in favor of “tri-parenting.” In the remaining states — Alaska, Delaware, Florida, New York, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania, and Washington State — only lower courts have addressed the matter.

The next geographical area to contemplate legalizing “tri-parenting,” according to The Associated Press, is the nation’s capital.

Though it doesn’t appear any three-parent situations have been legally recognized in Washington, D.C., some family-law attorneys are pointing to a new law regarding surrogate pregnancies that does not address a particular number of “intended parents” who can have contact with a surrogate.

The law, which does block the surrogate herself from having parental rights, went into effect in April and could offer “a substantial open door” to “tri-parenting,” family-law attorney Christopher Locey said.

One last thing…
Watch TheBlaze live and on demand on any device, anywhere, anytime.
try premium
Exclusive video
All Videos
Watch live and on demand on any device, anywhere, anytime.
Start a FREE Trial
Worth a look
Newsletter

Get the news that matters most delivered to your inbox.