Analyst: Gold Is Still a 'Safe Haven' -- Despite Being Undermined by the Fed

John Browne is a Senior Economic Consultant to Euro Pacific Capital and he recently had some very interesting analyses concerning precious metals, specifically, gold.

In an article written for Euro Pacific Capital, Browne starts by railing against the abject failure of the Congressional supercommittee:

The Congressional Super Committee, which had been created over the summer by the House and Senate to avoid responsibility for the debt crisis, chose to avoid responsibility itself. In so doing the Committee has followed the path of least resistance and maximum irresponsibility. Given the likely after-effects, the outcome should be judged as criminal dereliction of duty. It should now be crystal clear to even the most casual observer that a solution to the U.S. debt crisis will not come from within, but will be imposed, perhaps brutally, from without.

And though this may be true, Browne believes that the U.S. has been doing itself a diservice by directing its focus solely on the problems of the supercommittee while it should be focusing on actions being taken overseas:

. . . institutional investors remained focused on Paris and Brussels where beleaguered European banks continue to suffer from dangerous overexposure to bad sovereign debt. To avoid these risks institutions are locked into a flight to what they perceive as ‘safety.’ Despite the abject failure of American politicians many of these institutions may be flooding into U.S. dollars and U.S. Treasuries. The buying has driven yields to historic lows.

This unexpected fund flow is acting as a fortuitous camouflage for the U.S. Congress. With the U.S. dollar rising, and U.S. interest rates falling, the inability of Congress to curb its profligate spending habits appears in some eyes to be less urgent. At the same time, commonly held secure investments such as precious metals, appear to be increasingly volatile and viewed increasingly as less of a safe haven.

However, Browne is certain that these two approaches are “flawed” and run the risk of investor disappointment.

Why?

First, it is likely that a collapse of either the euro or the European banking system will flow rapidly to America, threatening U.S. banks, the U.S. Treasury market and even the continued viability of the fiat dollar-based monetary system. In short, the U.S. dollar and U.S. Treasury bonds are two massive but latent bear traps.

Simply put, investors need to be careful of both. Browne continues:

Second, the safe haven aspects of precious metals, especially that of gold have been distorted by the Fed. Most debtor central banks and politicians would be pleased by any reduction in the embarrassing ‘safe haven’ image of gold, and have historically done all that they could to undermine confidence in the gold market.

And this is the part of his analysis where Browne unloads on the Fed:

It is important to recognize the major distortion that Fed Chairman Bernanke has thrust into the gold price. Under his guidance, the Federal Reserve has abused its monopoly power to manipulate short-term interest rates, which are currently 1.5 percent below the level of inflation, a level that has inflicted, and will continue to inflict, untold damage on the economy. Negative real rates deny investors a secure economic repository for their cash. In reaction, many have used gold as an alternative to replace bank deposits. This added demand has boosted the marginal prices of gold and silver.

Today, precious metals appear to track stock markets. When stock markets rise, investors tend to hold their accumulated cash not in zero interest bank deposits, but in precious metals, driving prices upwards. When stocks fall in price, investors sell precious metals to raise cash to meet normal cash requirements including redemptions and margin calls, adding enormously to the marginal price volatility of precious metals. However, this volatility does not foreclose on gold’s ability to retain its value when confronted with additional rounds of currency debasement.

Second, precious metals are not merely a hedge against inflation. They are insurance also against financial catastrophe. With quantitative easing likely to be the recommended panacea for recession, we may face economic recession accompanied by financial inflation and a threat to the fiat monetary system. If this disaster transpires, one major safe haven could be precious metals. As a result, Fed inspired short-term price volatility should not deter investors accumulating positions on price dips.

If this is true, and that the U.S. economy faces the very real threat of "economic recession accompanied by financial inflation and threat to the fiat monetary system," what is the bottom line?

"In short, the current news from both sides of the Atlantic should provide further reasons to feel comfortable with precious metals," writes Browne.

Indeed, gold may be more than a good bet against a "financial catastrophe"--it may be the only bet.

(h/t Business Insider)