Indiana woman convicted on rape, murder charges after lesbian app threesome ends in baseball bat beatings, 2 dead

An Indiana woman was convicted on rape and murder charges related to a threesome encounter that ended with baseball bat beatings and left two people dead.

On Wednesday, a Vanderburgh County jury found Heidi Kathleen Carter, 37, guilty of six felonies: three counts of criminal confinement, two counts of aiding, inducing, or causing rape, and one count of aiding, inducing, or causing murder.

Carter was arrested in October 2021was arrested in October 2021 at her Evansville home — where she invited a couple she met on a "lesbian dating app" to have threesome sex. The three drank alcohol and took drugs before engaging in the threesome, according to court documents.

Carter's then-boyfriend, Carrey Hammond, walked into the house during the sex session. Hammond allegedly became enraged and used a baseball bat to severely beat the man involved in the threesome — 50-year-old Tim Ivy.

The surviving victim told the courtroom on Monday, "The next thing I know there’s a man bursting through the door with a baseball bat attacking us."

The woman added that Hammond "swung (the bat) like a golf club."

Carter and Hammond reportedly restrained Ivy with duct tape and the female victim with duct tape and velcro straps. The female victim said Carter and Hammond were "beating and abusing them for hours."

The unnamed woman testified that Hammond raped her while Carter pointed a gun at her.

The Courier & Press reported, "Carter would go on to hold her at gunpoint as Hammond raped her, the woman testified. She said Carter appeared 'excited' and 'angry' as she told Hammond to 'do anything he wants to me.'"

The victim told investigators that Carter was threatening to kill the couple as she was holding a gun. Carter allegedly said that she "knows someone in Indianapolis who knows how to hide a body."

The woman said Carter left the house for a "short time," and while she was gone, Hammond strangled Ivy to death with his belt after he attempted to take off the duct tape restraints. Hammond purportedly wrapped Ivy's dead body in blankets. When Carter returned, she helped Hammond move Ivy's body to another room, according to court documents.

Carter and Hammond hired a housekeeper to clean two bedrooms for an upcoming landlord inspection. The cleaning person noticed blood on Carter's shoes and a gun in her hand, according to Fox News. The couple then ordered pizza.

The housekeeper heard a female crying for help upstairs. She "went to sit down on what she thought was a pile of pillows and blankets" and realized that it was a human body, according to the arrest report.

The housekeeper told the couple that she had to leave, but Hammond and Carter reportedly told her that she could not leave. Carter allegedly told the woman that she had "better listen" to Hammond. The housekeeper managed to escape the house and found a state trooper.

Law & Crime reported, "When police arrived at the house, Hammond left home aggressively and held an object shaped like a handgun, police said. Officers opened fire, killing him. Police said he had a metal and plastic object that looked like a gun in his hand, and police described Hammond’s death as suicide by cop."

Carter was arrested.

Carter confessed to police that she was making threats with the gun, but said she was only "pretending" to help Hammond to appease, according to the arrest report.

Heidi Carter found guilty on all charges in Stinson Avenue murder-rape investigationwww.youtube.com

Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up!